ACRA Annual Return From 20 Oct 2026: Confirm Particulars, CEO Question
Since 20 October 2026, a Singapore company filing its ACRA annual return must confirm that the particulars of its directors, chief executive officers, secretaries, auditors…
Published: 22 June 2026 · Reviewed by Ray Tay, Co-Founder & Director, VIVOS PTE. LTD. (ACRA Filing Agent FA20240323 · MOM EA Licence 24S2425)
Most startups that fail do so because they run out of cash or never find product–market fit, but a large share of failures trace back to the founding team rather than the product. In CB Insights’ post-mortem analysis, “not the right team” was cited in 14-23% of startup failures, and Harvard Business School research finds that interpersonal “people problems” among founders, not market or technical issues, drive the majority of failures in high-potential startups.
In Singapore, founder fallouts turn destructive when there is no founders’ agreement and weak governance: no vesting, no leaver terms, no way to break a 50/50 deadlock, and no clear reserved-matter controls. When that happens, founders may resort to statutory remedies, an oppression action under section 216 of the Companies Act 1967, a derivative action under section 216A, or, in the worst case, an application to wind the company up on the “just and equitable” ground under section 125(1)(i) of the Insolvency, Restructuring and Dissolution Act 2018. The fix is preventive: a well-drafted founders’ agreement and a sound constitution from day one.
Founder disputes rarely begin with a single dramatic event. They build from unresolved questions that were never written down at the start: who owns how much, who decides what, who does the work, and what happens if someone leaves. The VIVOS panel’s starting point is that the seeds of most disputes are planted on day one, when co-founders are aligned, optimistic, and reluctant to negotiate hard terms with people they trust.
The evidence backs this up. Across CB Insights’ startup post-mortems, “not the right team” appears as a cause in 14-23% of cases, depending on the dataset, alongside the better-known killers of running out of cash and building something with no market need. Harvard Business School professor Noam Wasserman, who studied roughly 10,000 founders for The Founder’s Dilemmas, found that interpersonal “people problems” within the founding team, rather than product, market, or technical failures, account for the majority of failures among high-potential startups.
Common flashpoints include unequal effort against equal equity, disagreement over strategy or pace, a founder wanting to exit, dilution from fundraising, and the simple drift that occurs as a company scales and roles change.
Beyond the legal mechanics, founder disputes are fundamentally human. The panel’s discussion of recognition and egos points to a pattern many founders will recognise: as a company grows, contributions become harder to measure, credit becomes contested, and personal identity gets bound up with the business. A disagreement over a product decision can quickly become a proxy for a deeper question of whose vision the company follows.
These tensions also create real human-resources and legal risk. When a founder is also a director and an employee, a fallout can simultaneously raise employment issues (a founder’s removal or resignation), directors’ duties (acting in the company’s interests, not one’s own), and shareholder rights.
Singapore’s framework reflects this overlap: a founder who is sidelined can be both an aggrieved employee and an aggrieved shareholder, and the conduct complained of, exclusion from management, being cut out of information, or having decisions pushed through without consultation, is exactly the kind of behaviour the oppression remedy under section 216 of the Companies Act 1967 is designed to address.
The single most effective protection against a destructive dispute is a founders’ agreement (often combined with, or expanded into, a shareholders’ agreement) put in place at incorporation. Under Singapore law this is a private, contractual document, it is not filed with ACRA and is not required to incorporate a company, which means founders can negotiate candid, tailored terms that stay confidential. It sits alongside the company’s constitution, which is the public, mandatory governing document filed with ACRA.
A good founders’ agreement answers, in advance, the questions that later cause fights. The clauses below are general good practice in the Singapore market rather than statutory requirements, and they should be drafted to fit your specific cap table and plans.
Clauses every founders’ agreement should include
| Clause | What it does |
|---|---|
| Share vesting & reverse vesting | Founder equity “earns in” over time so an early departer cannot keep full equity. The Singapore norm is reverse vesting, shares issued upfront but subject to company buy-back or forfeiture if a founder leaves before vesting, typically over three to four years with a one-year cliff. |
| Leaver provisions (good vs bad leaver) | Defines what happens to a departing founder’s shares. A “good leaver” (e.g. illness) usually keeps vested shares, often subject to buy-back at fair value; a “bad leaver” (e.g. misconduct or breach) typically has shares bought back at nominal value. Unvested shares are generally forfeited. |
| Deadlock-breaking mechanism | Resolves a stalemate, which is acute for 50/50 founders. Options include a chairperson’s casting vote, an independent director, escalation to mediation, or buy-sell “shoot-out” clauses (Russian roulette or Texas shoot-out). |
| Drag-along & tag-along rights | Drag-along lets a selling majority compel the minority to sell on the same terms (clearing a clean exit for a buyer); tag-along lets the minority join a majority sale on the same terms (protecting them from being left behind). |
| Reserved matters | Key decisions needing more than a simple majority, often a 75% special resolution or unanimous/investor consent, such as issuing shares, taking on debt above a threshold, changing the business, or selling the company. |
| Roles, time & remuneration | Sets each founder’s scope, expected commitment and pay, pre-empting disputes over “who does what” and whether contributions justify the equity split. |
| IP assignment | Each founder assigns the intellectual property they create to the company, so core assets belong to the company, not an individual, which is critical for fundraising and acquisition due diligence. |
| Restrictive covenants & confidentiality | Non-compete and non-solicit terms plus confidentiality. In Singapore these are prima facie void as restraint of trade and enforceable only if they protect a legitimate proprietary interest and are reasonable in scope, duration and geography, so they must be tightly drafted. |
| Dispute resolution clause | Sets a defined path, typically negotiation, then mediation and/or arbitration, keeping disputes private and out of open court. |
Founders’ agreements work hand in hand with good governance. Every Singapore company must adopt a constitution at incorporation, the single governing document that, since the Companies (Amendment) Act 2014, replaced the former Memorandum and Articles of Association, and it must be filed with ACRA. ACRA prescribes a Model Constitution that simple companies can adopt, while companies with investors or unusual share structures use a customised version. Altering the constitution requires a special resolution (at least 75% of votes cast), with the change lodged with ACRA within 14 days.
Because the constitution is public and binds all members as a statutory contract, while a shareholders’ agreement is private and binds only its signatories, the two must be drafted to align. Sensitive economics, vesting, leaver buy-back prices, drag and tag, usually live in the private agreement, but protections that need to bind everyone reliably (such as compulsory buy-back or transfer restrictions) should also be reflected in the constitution.
Sound governance also means meeting baseline ACRA obligations: at least one director ordinarily resident in Singapore, a qualified company secretary appointed within six months, a register of members, a register of registrable controllers, and timely annual filings. Reserved matters, the list of decisions requiring super-majority or unanimous approval, are the practical heart of governance for founders, because they determine who can do what without the others’ agreement.
Not every disagreement needs formal intervention, and escalating too fast can entrench positions. The panel’s framing is to escalate in proportion to the problem: start with a direct, documented conversation; if that fails, use the agreement’s dispute mechanism (often a structured negotiation, then mediation); and reserve formal legal remedies for genuine deadlock, misconduct, or conduct that is unfairly prejudicial to a shareholder. Keeping clear written records throughout, board minutes, decisions, and communications, matters, because if a dispute does reach a tribunal or court, the contemporaneous record is what the decision-maker relies on.
Where conduct crosses into unfairness, Singapore’s Companies Act 1967 provides statutory remedies. A member can seek relief under section 216 where the company’s affairs are being conducted, or directors’ powers exercised, in a manner that is oppressive, in disregard of a member’s interests, or unfairly discriminatory or otherwise prejudicial; the unifying test the courts apply is “commercial unfairness.” The court has wide discretion under section 216(2), and the most common remedy is an order that one party buy out the other’s shares at a fair value.
Where the wrong is done to the company rather than to a member personally, for example, a director diverting opportunities, a member can apply for leave to bring a statutory derivative action in the company’s name under section 216A, which requires 14 days’ notice, good faith, and that the action appears to be prima facie in the company’s interests.
How a dispute is resolved matters as much as the underlying rights. Founder disputes often suit mediation because it is confidential, faster and cheaper than litigation, and, crucially, it preserves relationships and lets the parties (not a judge) shape the outcome.
Singapore is a global hub for all three routes: mediation through the Singapore Mediation Centre and the Singapore International Mediation Centre; arbitration through the Singapore International Arbitration Centre; and litigation through the Singapore Courts. Mediated cross-border settlements are also enforceable internationally under the Singapore Convention on Mediation, in force since September 2020.
Dispute-resolution options compared
| Mediation | Arbitration | Litigation | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Binding? | Non-binding until a settlement is signed; that settlement is then enforceable | Binding final award; very limited appeal | Binding judgment, subject to appeal |
| Private or public? | Private & confidential | Private & confidential | Public (open court) |
| Who decides? | The parties; a mediator only facilitates | A tribunal the parties appoint | A judge appointed by the State |
| Speed & cost | Fastest, generally cheapest | Usually faster/cheaper than court | Typically slowest, most costly |
| Preserves relationship? | Highest | Moderate | Lowest |
| Typical use | Early founder fallouts; preserving the working relationship | A binding private decision where an arbitration clause exists | A statutory court remedy (e.g. s 216) or a public judgment is needed |
Litigation is unavoidable for certain remedies, because some relief can only be granted by a court. A section 216 oppression claim is a court action, and so is an application to wind a company up. In a true, permanent deadlock, commonly two equal shareholders who can no longer cooperate and have no mechanism to break the impasse, a member may apply to wind the company up on the “just and equitable” ground under section 125(1)(i) of the Insolvency, Restructuring and Dissolution Act 2018 (IRDA).
The Singapore Courts expressly list “deadlock in the management of the company” as an example of when this ground applies. Winding up is a remedy of last resort: where a less drastic option such as a share buy-out is available and the petitioner is acting unreasonably in seeking liquidation instead, the court can decline to wind the company up.
Founders are often too close to the conflict to resolve it alone. The panel’s closing theme, bringing in outside help, including the role of a counsellor or neutral facilitator, reflects a practical truth: a trusted third party can de-escalate, separate the personal from the commercial, and help founders reach a workable outcome before positions harden into litigation.
Corporate advisers, a company secretary, an independent director, and where needed a mediator or lawyer each play a part, and the earlier they are engaged, the more options remain open. The most valuable outside help, though, arrives before any dispute: getting the founders’ agreement, the constitution and the governance framework right at incorporation is far cheaper and far less painful than untangling a fallout later.
Getting your structure, constitution and founders’ arrangements right from day one is the most reliable protection against a costly fallout. VIVOS helps founders incorporate and govern their companies properly in Singapore.
Hello and welcome everyone. Delighted to have you here today for our round table that cuts to the heart of what causes all too many companies to struggle. According to Harvard Business Review, 65% of startups that fail don't go down because of cash flow or profits, but because of internal misalignment and disputes. In other words, it's all too often not the business model, it's the boardroom. And that's why today's conversation really matters. I think a lot of the triggers relate to personalities, supporting actors, contributing beyond what the founder acknowledges. The boardroom for better or for worse is a SAS pit of very big eos when it
comes to money. It's always uh can be a bit couch. All right. What you think you need to think about would be uh how are you going to settle, you know, is you catch it much earlier as early as possible and take action on it. Meet Melanie Hoe, partner at One Partnership and head of enterprise disputes. She's the go-to council when stakes are high and reputations are on the line. Next, we have Jeremiah Huang, principal at Everstead Law, named one of Singapore's most influential lawyers by SB and a legal 500 NextGen partner. Next, we have Mr. Ray with over 15 years of banking experience and
now as co-founder at VIVOS, he guides businesses through ASEAN expansion. And finally, we have Mark Tay, associate director at Asia Practice with a sharp eye for strategy and a steady hand in complex cases. I cannot imagine if my wife now and say, "You know what? We love you, but I think we should get a postnup done." Hello and welcome everyone. Delighted to have you here today for our round table that cuts to the heart of what causes all too many companies to struggle. Let's be honest, most boardroom blowups and disputes don't just happen overnight. First, they simmer, slowly they build, and then unfortunately, often boom.
In fact, according to Harvard Business Review, 65% of startups that fail don't go down because of cash flow or profits, but because of internal misalignment and disputes. In other words, it's all too often not the business model, it's the boardroom. And that's why today's conversation really matters. And we've invited today three legal powerhouses who've not just seen these situations play out, they've helped prevent them, fix them, and redesign governance that works. First, Jeremiah Wong. Recognized as one of Singapore's most influential lawyers under 40, Jeremiah is a go-to adviser on M&A, corporate governance, and conflict mediation. and his track record spans the capital markets compliance and
pretty much everything in between. And second, we have Melanie Hoe, head of professional and enterprise disputes at Wong Partnership. Melanie has led some of the region's most complex white collar investigations, and she's also the first Singaporean appointed to be the appellet board at Dubai Healthcare City. Last but not least, Mark Tay with a sharp focus on crossber finance and restructuring. marks the one companies go to when they need governance tightened, realigned, or rebuilt quietly and effectively. These aren't just legal voices. They're conflict deescalators, strategic thinkers, and governance architects. So, settle in. You're about to hear what happens behind those closed doors and how the smart
companies stay one step ahead. So, we're going to get get started today with some questions around this topic. So, um let's begin. Um, I was going to ask the group here and and maybe I'll put the first question to Melanie. Um, from your experience of of enterprise disputes, what are the most common triggers you've seen uh in boardroom conflicts in fast growing or founder companies? Yes. As you mentioned, Ivan, I think a lot of the triggers relate to personalities. Now personalities beyond the lead actor which we know to be the founder and then you have what we know to be the supporting actors and as
a company grows you have some supporting actors perhaps contributing beyond what the founder acknowledges whether it be in terms of bonuses remuneration scope of work duties um the dissatisfaction from a perspective of the supporting actors is what I see to be the main trigger. Mark, uh what's what sort of experience or examples have you seen? I think I agree with Melanie, but I think the other uh trigger would probably be um a bit of a lack of documentation or some sort of governance structure especially in uh founded le companies uh which have just uh been incorporated or started. So um I think uh many of
them view uh legal cost as an extraneous cost that need not be incurred at the start and that is unfortunately I feel a bit of a a bit of an issue because uh we often have clients coming to us with already a growing dispute which could have easily been settled by a proper documentation of you know uh expectations at the start. Yeah, it's it's such a common situation, isn't it? Uh you realize that it's it's so complicated to unwind if you haven't done the preparation in advance. Um but that people neglect this up up front. And Jeremiah, what what's been your experience in this case?
So I think Melanie really hit the nail on the head here as to what you know moves an enterprise dispute and kicks it into high gear, right? A lot of times it's personality. The boardroom for better or for worse is a cess pit of very big egos very often, more often than not. Um, but for me as a corporate lawyer, I try to see the best in people. Uh, I don't think anybody joins a board to just force upon others his or her views. And I think the really or at least from what I've seen in my experience has been this, right? Um, very often
when enterprise disputes occur, it's not so much, you know, a personality thing at the start, although that really is what, you know, as I mentioned, right, rocket ships the whole thing into this massive problem down the line. Um, I think very often it starts with divergent visions and strategies about the business. Like I said, no one's actually joining a board to just force upon other people their ideas. um they join a board because they've got ideas about a business and how it should be run. uh usually usually with profit making in mind and you know when it comes to money it's always uh can be
a bit touchy right and you know people with different views are going to clash if they think that their view is going to sound in a better outcome either for the organization as a whole or for them individually they are going to insist upon it for me when I think about enterprise disputes and I were to trace the genesis of it uh very often it starts with just a disagreement on you know the business either as a whole or on a specific topic right and then that's where personalities come into play you know it then you know takes that little seed that's been planted that
little disagreement that doubt that insecurity and then it just propels it into a life of its own and then what Mark said about documentation that goes very much into amilarating and mitigating um some of you know the negative effects and adverse consequences of uh disputes that get blown up into uh into something more than uh you know everybody sort of expected. Yeah, great points Jeremiah. I guess everybody on the panel seems to agree that disputes will inevitably come along and that with egos and sensitivities and personalities, these probably can't be avoided and they need to be prepared for. And I think I I heard from
all of the the panelists as well that actually there's a lot you could do in advance uh to prepare yourself for how you could manage this. Um, you know, Melanie, back to yourself, you know, what what kind of advice would you would you give people to say, you know, if you see red flags or you see warning signals, how how would you prepare? Um, what what could be done? So, the the starting point, let's move a step back perhaps before the warning signs and the red flags. I I think a starting point uh would be to set up what I would call an internal structure.
It could be in terms of designation. So there is a very clear delineation of duties of scope like I said that feeds the recognition part of the trigger I was mentioning right you attribute a scope of duties to the right person and that person feels that they are properly recognized. That's the first obviously I'm talking about a holistic vision. Uh so I agree totally with Jeremiah that there must be a road map to the vision the 5 10 20 year road map that we all see in all companies for our firms as well and this is going to be the seed that drives the business
growth with each pilot taking one segment of the business fundamentals forward. Then the second part which I think Mark uh alluded to would be what I we would call governance. What what the corporate and and dispute lawyers would call corporate governance. And this sets out the fundamentals of the financial governance regulatory risk or compliance which is the the the term of of the year risk compliance regulation as well as of course HR does cause problems as well if you don't manage that reputational risk are very closely related to HR risk. So the these I would say would be the three uh key areas of any
business whether in a founder setup with the vision of a 10-year growth upscaling themselves into multi-jurisdictional you you need to have these three fundamentals and red flags would be when someone doesn't want these fundamentals to be placed. So again, I agree with Jeremiah. No one comes in to a race trying to stop the race. People are joining to add fuel to speed up the growth of the company. But when you see an individual or maybe segments of the company sort of impeding what would be a road map that would be in the best interest of the company I think one has to stop take stock
and see whether that person or persons are the right fit and is it better to cut now or to perhaps manage the situation in a consultative manner to diffuse any potential potential triggers, red flags. Thank you, man. Jeremiah, any any practical examples or um situations you've from your experience that that you've seen this sort of situation and and what have you been able to do? I I do and actually um it ties in very well with Melanie's point and I'm so glad that she led her her views with you know by taking a step back and acknowledging that you know if you're only reacting when
the early warning signs the red flags appear you might be a little too late you might be a little too late um and and this goes to Mark's point as well right that really ideally you want to be in a situation where you've already got a very clear process and procedure in place um you know to manage and to deal with you know these so-called warning signs or red flags as you put it or I much rather the term just issues right you know points of disagreement early on I have a very real world example of this um so I was quite lucky to represent
A now I can't go into the details because this is a public deal and it's out there in the wild. Um so I I won't go into the details for fear of my client being identified. Uh but the gist is I represented a top shelf specialist in their field and they did a joint venture with this other company that is a conglomerate in in another jurisdiction. And because you know it involved two very sophisticated very savvy parties uh managed run by very big personalities the negotiations in relation to the shareholders agreement um were not the easiest. Right. Everyone had different views citing their past experience
and saying how well it worked for them. We got to the deadlock resolution mechanism eventually and I just couldn't agree with their lawyers as to how to deal you know to deal with it and eventually I guess all the directors got sick of us as well and they eventually gave the instruction to both councils. Drop this point. Replace the entire deadlock clause with just the simplest write up saying that in the event of any dispute, both sides shall mutually agree on the approach. Which sounds very nice until you realize that the whole point of a deadlock clause is to deal with the situation where parties
can't deal, you know, can't find their own path and own way forward. Yeah. But that was their instructions. uh and you know we had to aced you know sometimes our clients again for better or for worse think they know better than we do and I cannot profess to know more than my clients you know I can only give advice you know from the way I see things but they insisted upon it and that was what was done one year later unfortunately uh a dispute did actually arise they couldn't agree about how to manage a particular project and then you know we turn to the shareholders
agreement of the joint venture how do we move forward from here and the shareholders agreement said as I said that both parties shall mutually agree on the way forward but the things they couldn't agree on the way forward so what happened in the end well what happened in the end was that both sides were threatening to sue each other for you know adjacent breaches of the shareholders agreement Demand letters were sent and eventually both sides realized that no one was going to walk away the winner. And as many of these uh cases eventually pan out, a settlement agreement was signed pursuant to which the joint
venture was voluntarily dissolved. But the entire process took over a year. multiple councils were appointed not just in Singapore and in that jurisdiction but disputes lawyers you know involved in other jurisdictions um that the joint venture had gone into for various reasons because you know there were assets there money there and things like that. The whole thing could have been avoided and dealt with efficiently if RPS had as Mark said right you know put in place proper documentation proper procedures proper processes to deal with a situation in which they disagreed and unfortunately they did not and that's what happened. So coming into this call I
did a check uh how much legal fees were spent uh in the leadup to resolution. Wow. It was something just on my client's end. And let me just state for the avoidance of doubt that most of this didn't go to me. All right? I'm a corporate lawyer, right? I'm not a business. Most of this didn't go to me. Uh they spent six figures US just getting to that settlement. Whereas had they agreed from the start, right? uh my fee already included working out the shareholders agreement. They could have saved themselves that entire sum of money and that extended period of time and moved on with
their business, gotten on with the project either individually or with someone else. But yeah, you know, they didn't and that's what happened. So that's my example for you. Wow. Thank you, Jeremiah. That's a real cautionary tale. Um and and an example of when when you try and even uh but you don't do it right, it still can be a problem. Mark, do you have any uh similar or perhaps maybe more positive stories that worked out uh worked out better um that you could share with us please? I I think I mean first of all I just wanted to say I agree entirely with Melanie Andrea
Maya um in terms of how we of we actually I don't really have that many positive stories to share but I do have some clients coming to us with again uh disputes already on the hand and I imagine how this all could be avoided um at the initial stage of documentation. So I think really one big big flag right uh would be that um if I mean I get that businesses would want to push out their products quicker. They want to push out their pictures to investors quicker um and all of them under time constraints that uh not necessarily that lawyers can fully understand. But
I would caution and probably let all my clients know uh potential clients know that they really need to set aside that time period for discussion for documentation to take place in terms of what are the expectations, what are the agreed uh dispute resolution mechanisms and all these need to be hashed out before they proceed on to the business proper. uh that would save so much time, so much cost down the road that would remove all the uh you know feelings of personal attacks. You know it's not really a personal attack. People are just trying to make decisions according to the how the document has stated
and how it has been agreed. So you can actually move on to business faster instead of dwelling on you know disputes the whole time. Yeah, very true. And and Ray, we've we've worked with a few clients in this space with disputes in recent months. Um any any uh learnings you think that will be useful to share here? So of I mean obviously we are in the business of helping clients start start their business as well, right? So a lot of conversations that we have with clients is now your friends, now your best friends, your husband and wife, your father and son, whatever relationship it is,
right? You have all you have to put in the worst case scenario. You know what if you get a divorce? You know what if you're no longer friends, right? Uh on a personal level, you no longer have that relationship. Can you still deal with this person on a commercial basis? Um if you can't, then it's a recipe for disaster, right? Your disputes will all arise because of this. So very often when we have two friends coming in, oh happily we have this great business plan, you know, we're going to make millions out of it. Very often we just tell them, hey, you know, who is
the who is the main guy here? There has to be a main guy, right? It can't be a strict 50/50. Then what if you have a deadlock, you know, who's going to make who's who has the veto vote, right? So um I think very much that's the that's the advice that we can give to our clients. uh and yeah through through the recent experience with that few disputes that we managed to to help mediate uh I think again a lot of times if you catch it much earlier as early as possible and take action on it less actions are required uh the dispute has not
deepened to a level that they don't talk to each other or to a to a stage where the relationship cannot be recovered uh then that would be you know uh you know acting early will be highly ideal. Very practical uh advice and experience. Thank you Ray. And it's obviously we have a powerhouse here of experience in corporate law and dispute resolution and mediation and um you know between the panel it' be great to to get everyone's perspectives but picture the picture that that sunny day when all the the founders or shareholders are all happily celebrating their new venture and getting started. and they all agree,
well, no, we don't need to worry about this. We don't need a shareholder agreement. We don't need a founders agreement. We don't need dispute resolution or governance like we talked about. What would each of you say to those founders at that point in time to help them understand maybe the value of giving some thought to to preparing for how you would handle disputes when they may inevitably arrive further down the road? Um, maybe Mark, you want to you want to kick us off? Sure. I mean, I would be a bit of a Debbie Downer. I would actually uh caution them. Okay. Um it's great that
you have all this in place, but what you additionally need to have in place or what you additionally need to think about would be uh how are you going to settle, you know, uh not so not so savory scenarios, right? That would paint out some scenarios for them. Okay, if this happens, what are you guys going to do? If that happens, do you have a process in place to settle that? So, um I'll play a bit of the devil's advocate. Uh at the same time, of course, you know, I won't discourage them, but you know, certain things that they may have agreed upon without uh
the benefit of legal counsel, I I would try to manage that as well. Yeah. Yeah. Great point, Mark. And Jeremiah, how about you? How would you try and get into help them on their way? Oh, I'd be I'd do the exact opposite. Um, you know, at that point, if they're all out dancing in the sun, I would drink their champagne and celebrate with them because at that point in time, it's too late, right? They've already entered into agreement with each other. They've already subscribed for their shares. I'm not going to rain on their parade and tell them that, "Hey guys, you know what? This marriage
is going to fail." Nah, you don't you don't do that, right? I mean, you know, you you go for weddings uh between some people who you know should get married to each other. You don't object to the wedding and go, "Guys, you don't do this. It's going to end in divorce. I I'm not going to do that. I'm going to go there, drink the champagne, eat the buffet, wish them the best, and hope nothing happens." But then, of course, you know, if uh I don't know if I can say this given that this is supposed to be a recording, but if [ __ ] hits
the fan, uh I would be prepared to give Melanie and Mark's number. So I'm not this I'm able to thisa after uh when it hits the fan I will Melanie and Mark saying hey guys um this thing happened can you help and that's probably the best advice I can give if you've waited till after you've subscribed for shares in the joint venture you know you've put your money in at that juncture it's a little bit too late because the money's already gone in how are you going to incentivize somebody who's already done a deal with you to then back away from whatever benefits or obligations
or rights he may already have under the constitution which is itself a shareholders agreement. It is the overarching primary binding shareholders agreement between the company, the shareholders, the directors. You're not going to be able to do that. It's not something you're going to be able to do easily unless of course it's a quit pro type situation and the other side also sees some value in you know superseding that arrangement for him. So yeah, you know, I I wouldn't I wouldn't, as Mark said, right, beat Debbie Downer. I would, you know, jam the fun, friendly, you know, council, uh, you know, having fun with the rest
of the the directors and the shareholders. Well, perhaps, uh, Jeremiah, perhaps the most chilling advice of all of them would be to to to welcome them to proceed on and enjoy the legal fees that will ensue later on. Um, I might get to pause for thought. Melanie, how about you? What would your take be? Yeah, actually it happens more frequently than you can imagine. So I can understand why Jeremiah takes that that that view. Um in many sort of family high net worth families they they just run into JV sign it and then throw it on your table and say hey let's process this execute
this. Um so while it has been done you can't do a prenup because they're already married. I will certainly try a postnap postnap show. What does this mean? This means uh bringing the parties uh back together after the hangover, maybe the day after, bringing them all to your office, setting sort of uh I I'm very into fundamentals and checklist in case you haven't noticed. Uh because I I think this is objective. This is independent. It is not whichever party wants it or likes it. These are the tools that us legal professionals whether you're corporate or dispute lawyers will place before your client force them to
apply their minds to it collectively. Collectively and then taking a little bit of uh Mark's wisdom and say what would happen if this scenario how would you react? how would you react? How do you then together want the company to react? So I I would really force them to sit down um and then think through some of the issues, some of the risk factors, some of the SOPs. it it needn't be overly uh documented but conceptually some basic guidelines on how a company would want to react in a certain way if certain things happen and going back to the earlier point about uh negotiating certain
clauses. So what we have done for small medium uh enterprises because you don't want to overburden them with documentation paper and all that they don't want to do that they want to do business they want to make money I get it okay so what we do is have some non-negotiable clauses be it dispute clauses be it jurisdiction clauses law clauses whatever it might be for that so with this already preset term terms it would be sort of uh easier to move forward without having to negotiate every single terms. Visa v the internal uh company because when you are negotiating you are negotiating externally but what
happens more often than not is there's a lot of internal talk happening why because the fundamentals internally hasn't been decided. Okay. And when you get that out of the way, I think at least whether the deal goes through with that third party or not internally, it doesn't cause undue strain and pressures and disagreements. So that that would be what I do in this scenario. That makes a lot of sense. But so I'm I'm hearing the the clear voice of experience here from the the professionals in this space that um best of all is to consider this question even before you begin. So that that is
really the right place to to to to to grasp this nettle and to to define everything as much as you can. But of course if if you don't then after the fact and as early as possible is still better than than not and to get involved. And even you know Melanie to your point even the very simplistic basics of jurisdiction or process or mediation will help you a lot in later situation if you need to get into difficult complicated situations. So so sorry I'm just going to jump in here and just throw my two cents in. Unsolicited two cents if I may add. Um I
I completely understand where Melanie and Mark are coming from. But here's the thing, right? If you wait until someone is married to then sit them down and have that discussion about whether or not to do a postnup, you're going to put a sour taste in everybody's mouth. And it may not end as badly as you know we very j you know very jaded lawyers think you know such unions typically do but you don't want to sorry let me please edit this properly uh but the point that I want to make is essentially this right doing it postf facto after the fact is going to leave
us very sour taste in everybody's mouth. And in a union, uh, a joint venture or a marriage, you don't want to start that relationship off that way. And here's the thing, right? You can't force somebody to sign something that they don't want to sign, but you're already tied down together. And there is a shareholders agreement in play, and that's your constitution. You know, it if it's a standard constitution, then equity is king. Of course, there are minority rights, but equity is generally clean, right? Because equity gets to vote in order of directors. B directors gets day-to-day management of the company, so on so forth. But
yeah, you know, it's just important to keep in mind that if you've already done this, right, do you really want to raise this now? What what is the upside and the downside to it? Things work out. You get all those procedures that we talked about done. So, not too late. you managed to salvage the situation a little bit, but what's the downside? The downside is that you piss off your partner. Uh, you know, you then become a little bit suspicious of him or her, you know, in the event that, you know, he or she does not want to sign whatever you're asking for. It's not
a great way to start a relationship or a union. And it then basically sets in motion that failure really really early on. You know, which is why I said, you know, if if people are already celebrating their marriage together, at that point it might be a little too late. Yeah, I I just want to jump in here. So, I think that definitely very legitimate scenario that Jeremiah was uh mentioning. So to just to clarify when I'm a debut downer I usually whisper in the year of my client and basically just um paint some scenarios for them to consider. So it's not necessarily they would you
know go ahead to you know okay I need to get this done right now right after celebrations but it's more of you know they seeing as how to I mean each business relationship is different they need to also calibrate and know how to work certain things in certain requests in along the way and I guess that is a relationship actually that the council as well as the clients will build up uh together with um you know the counterparty um it's more than just um you know 3 months of work probably is a year-long relationship. So they might come back to us uh to uh for
you know more advice on how to uh work certain uh provision into the existing agreement that they have. Um yeah so I think it it still can work just that you know we need to be a bit more calibrated about it. Yeah you have to manage it very carefully. I cannot imagine if I my wife now and said, "You know what? We love you, but I think we should get a postnap done." Bro, I would sleep outside. I would sleep outside. And And here's the thing, right? And even if he gave me what I was asking for, me being the very neurotic lawyer that I
am, I would then be wondering, well, why did she agree to this? You know, and if she did not, I would then be thinking, well, why did she not give me that? It's only fair, right? And imagine whatever you're feeling, the other side's feeling as well. So, you know, that's why I say I I really like what Melanie led with, you know, um the second question posed to her, and that is that you really need to take a step back first. These things should be done sooner rather than later, which also ties in with Mark's main point as to why this, you know, why do
all these disputes occur, you know? Um and one of the points of failure is the lack of an agreement in relation to how they properly managed. So yeah, I I just realized I've got I've got IP cameras around me, you know, because I'm doing this recording from my house, you know, babe, I'm I'm not getting a post now for the record. So I think the the passion coming through here is built on, I'm sure, many years of pain and suffering in cases that you've worked on. Um pain and suffering not in my marriage. Pain and suffering in cases that we Yes. business-wise definitely not not
personal, I'm sure. and and and Jeremiah, you certainly undermined of course the the practical and the the realistic aspect of making sure that you do this before rather than after. So, so, so you know maybe Jeremiah if you want to come in again or or anyone else, but what is the the best approach then before consummating or getting started with the the new venture or the new business um that you're that you're planning to start? what is the best way of handling this um best practice- wise? Well, exactly what Melanie and Mark have already said. You know, ensure that you get in bed with someone
that you know you you can live and sleep with. Um and that applies equally to marriage and ensure that you've got an agreement in relation to how that union is going to be run together jointly early on. I I don't really have much else to add to that. You know, those are truisms that have, you know, stood time immemorial. I to play sort of devil's advocate, I I imagine that all of those people lining up in our office starting new ventures feel that they have exactly that and that they're completely confident. But Melanie, maybe I throw it to you. what what what is that best
practice document that uh that Jeremiah is speaking about, Mark has been speaking about, you've been sharing, what's the best way of of codifying this and preparing and protecting the the venture to go forward? No, I think all the the fundamentals that uh I've mentioned about how they wish to approach the the business. So they go first to the corporate lawyer and then they go and speak about what sort of business structure they want. Obviously these are the basics that need to be agreed on the shareholding. If one wants to talk about the checklist of things they have to agree on how dividends are intended to
be taken out. I mean it might not be in there but I know everyone talks about it at part because we are talking about a revenue earning uh entity and moving forward if there are share options call options all sorts of mechanisms which allow people to add add on or exit depending are also put in I think my my learned uh corporate colleagues are best suited to explain the the details of that but for myself like I said um and I keep re repeating I think you must start on the basis that you have the same vision the same concept of how you want the
business to run how you want the business to grow what are you looking at five year 10 years once you have that shared vision and we keep analogizing to marriage for a reason because this is a marriage in business and once you have that sort of consolidated I think yes details certainly matter but where you're going to live how you're going to live uh are primary considerations before you even decide to go down the road of checking off the further details and the nitty-gritty well put yeah you can't overestimate that shared vision and Mark you want anything you want to come in on this yeah
don't have much to add um I think Melanie and Jeremiah have covered it quite well. So in terms of how this will all come into a document is you know usually a founders agreement or shareholders agreement and um there are certain I mean I'm sure some founders are already very much aware of what usually goes to these agreements um or some founders are actually aware of investor requirements but they would really clearly set out uh how certain defaults or certain disagreements should be settled whether it be a buyout whether it be a termination, whether it be uh you know move to a type of dispute
resolution such as uh mediation or negotiation. So um it's very important to have this document so that uh everyone has something to refer to. Everyone can at least agree on what they're going to do in terms of a dispute. If you're going to have a dispute and then you're going to dispute further on how you going to solve that dispute, you know, it's it's just uh too many, you know, disputes, too many disagreements for it to be settled uh quickly, settled expeditiously. So, yeah, thank you, Mark. Yeah, that's that's I I hope this is somewhat of a public service announcement for all of those uh
shareholders, business owners, uh founders, future founders out there to to to give consideration to. And but perhaps we also have to deal with the the practical reality that most of the people out there are going to for going to ignore what we said and plow on regardless. Um maybe as Jeremiah said, celebrate the the party first. Um let's imagine we're in a scenario where where the disputes come along and and we haven't necessarily got all of those um points defined. a as specialists, as legal experts, h how do you think there's a role for for specialists like yourselves to help um people people navigate these
situations maybe to mediate to find a common ground and how would you approach that? Um perhaps Melanie, if you want to do you want to start? Yes, maybe I start with an actual case uh that I did several years ago. it was two brothers uh running uh originally a father's company. So that's very common in Singapore. We are all in second, third, fourth uh generation businesses. Now um the situation arose uh as I said from the beginning um different personalities and they felt they were contributing different amounts than they uh thought they were. So in terms of remuneration obviously the CEO chairman of the board
was remunerated at a higher value and then you're talking about succession. One of them had a son who wanted to carry on the business the other didn't. So we mediated for about a year with very senior uh uh judges uh at SMC and I never thought it would settle. I really never thought it would settle. We all thought it would go on for a 8week trial. Uh, hooray to the dispute lawyers. But because this was a family uh dispute, I was trying my hardest to make sure that the relationship could be salvaged, which is almost impossible. Honestly, I think Jeremiah is nodding. It's almost impossible.
How do you have a corporate commercial fight? break up the brother the brothership brotherhood in the the the company and yet retain that. So what we came out was a very innovative plan. We allowed for let's say a three year five year I can't remember the details three year five years step off okay for the elder brother a three to five year step up to the son of the other brother which was brilliant because the younger brother wanted his son to also come into the family business but yet it was not to the disadvantage of the elder brother because he was just giving up one
part of the share not all. Then it was to be decided how the younger brother and the son wanted to to sort of uh proportionately share the additional shares. And with that step off, they were uh they were allowed to actually combine their expertise, take on all the clients that the older brother had closer relationships with and then agree on a final payout depending obviously on the on the uh net profits at the end of the five year or three year and give a huge sort of golden handshake to the older brother who would step off. So we managed that I thought beautifully because everyone
got most of what they wanted you see without destroying uh the business and that really took uh threats of I'm going to leave. I'm going to sue you. Let's see what the judge says. Throw down papers. that kind of a dispute because it is very emotional when you have a family especially an elder brother who feels that he has given the younger brother everything. So with that kind of very sort of traditional mentality, I think uh we we all went back happy and had our champagne thereafter. In order to also stabilize the ship, what we did was to put in sort of a trusted uh
very senior employee to help stabilize because the elder brother was of course worried whether the brother and the son were able to take over the business completely. So with that kind of like you know senior minister MM minister mentor concept we were able to also ensure that uh external parties optics wise they felt that the ship was stable enough for the contracts to continue with the company. So that allowed longevity of the relationship longevity of the business as well. That's a great story Melanie. Thank you. And I'm glad to hear that the the champagne can be popped even after these situations too. Um Mark, would
you like to share some some uh similar or other contrasting examples if you have them? I don't really have an example that comes to mind, but I think it's more of how it just goes to show how lawyers don't just take on a legal counsel role, but I think you take on a role of just being from the outside providing a different perspective to your clients. Um, because, you know, sometimes, uh, when there are, you know, brewing disputes, right? You know, parties tend to be very dark into their positions. I have to remind my clients, you know, um that, you know, while I'm looking out
for your interest and I do everything I can to protect your interest, you know, to consider that, you know, the counterparty position may not be something that is so unreasonable and to just provide a different perspective for them to consider to bring parties first to the negotiating table uh to then get each other to see the side of uh the other person uh to be able to get them to even consider speaking to each other, to consider working out a deal that can hopefully be a bit of a win-win at the end. It's not that easy and uh often times uh it does not work
out, but that's at least what we try to do in that situation. It's a great point, Mark. And Jeremiah, um any any examples you have on this as well? Uh I've got a couple uh for some reason I've been involved in a number of quite public board fights. Most recently just last month uh and I I can talk about this uh because well actually I don't know if I've been named I know my firm had been named but I was the lead partner on that SGX listed company bought five different camps with different views about what to do going forward. Um I will say this.
I think your question was you know how external consultants right like councils come in and help and a situation where parties have already started waring. And I think Melanie really nailed it right. We we test perceptions. We reality test what people feel you know about their positions. We explore alternatives and then we then break the dead law. um you know and you know external consultants uh would do very well because otherwise you know without a third parties point of view um you know each side may just cling on to their entrenched positions and and and views. I will say this though, so going back to
you know the point that we made at the start that um very often directors have larger than life personalities or egos. Often not always often. Um bringing councils in can be a bit of a double-edged sword, especially if the council doesn't act for the entire board or is advising as an independent but on one side. And I've got some personal experience here. Um, again because I've done a number of board fights, very public ones as well. So Melanie is the head of enterprise disputes at Wongpi, right? Mel, I'm sorry I I don't remember your full title. It's very long and you know it's a very
question. So and Mark himself, you know, associate director at at Asia Practice. These are learned friends who really uphold and extol the the the great profession of law. But you know not every council is like that and my experience has been you know sometimes uh councils come in with their own sort of agenda right either because they feel so passionately about their client's position that as a fiduciary they cannot help but encourage you know them to not settle and to persist in their position but you know at other times maybe because you know and I'm not saying that that many councils are like that but
there definitely exists a minority of us who you know sometimes put our professional involvement first. it it it can result in a situation where you know instead of actually helping to diffuse the situation as happened in Melan's example they actually make it worse either because they're actively encouraging the dispute and edging parties towards you know full-blown litigation arbitration or if not because you know they you know just their appointment sends the wrong image right the the wrong signal to the other side. Um one way forward in this situation is to have the board as a whole, the company as a whole, right? Not representing you
know any one side appoint council to advise everybody independently. So this council is is not conflicted. He really is just representing the position of the law and his views. And I think someone in that independent position is going to definitely help you know deescalate uh uh any dispute more likely than not anyway. Great points and a really interesting idea that you you you don't see it as confrontation with two sides. You put one party in the middle. Um you know before you need to go to a mediator, why not have a legal expert see the physician in the middle? Um and Ry, we've we've we've
faced some diff some cases recently where we've had, you know, we've spoken a lot about founders and shareholders, but also director disputes um where we've also faced issues in that space. You know, any any examples or or good stories hopefully that you can share about how we've leveraged support from legal console and professionals to to help get good outcomes in those kind of cases. I think I think the most recent case that we have seen is um a failure in director duties. Uh I wouldn't be so specific to name exactly what area but um it's very obvious the director have not carried out the required
responsibilities that um he's entrusted to do entrusted to have. um the shareholder wasn't too pleased um you know sitting outside of Singapore um they weren't sure you know what uh it entails to remove the director if they choose to eventually do so uh and what kind of recourse do they have. So we did uh refer the client to legal counsel uh one firm to to look after uh to give advice and um yeah and it's it's a ongoing situation at the current moment. Uh yeah so you it'll be good to hear from the experts on this panel um you know some ex some cases life
cases or you know past case studies that you have around this topic. Melanie, you want to anything you can share on this topic? Sure. I think this was probably a public listed. It was in the papers, but I won't name the the company. Uh we we helped with sort of the transition. So it founder company maybe 20 over years ago if we start counting from today in 10 years went into listing. Uh 11 11 12th year issues with the board because I think things started to to kind of unravel. Uh perhaps because some of the underlying governance fundamentals were not seamless. Um then there was
unhappiness as usual with the shareholders with one part of the board and wanted them removed. This is again I think Jeremiah is very familiar with these fights. But um we did again what I thought uh would never happen. We managed to use the different influence of the different board members to reach out to the key shareholders to try to agree on a middle ground uh CEO, acting CEO means agree to remove one individual rather than you know kill off the whole board. replace one of them with someone who was I would say neutral, not the most popular, not the most hated either. Someone neutral but
with a steady hand seemed to be independent as independent as one can be in certain situations and that averted certainly the entire breakup of of the board. I mean this this uh company has uh recently last year also been in papers with certain changes of the board members but what I want to say is um and Mark is is correct on this you know we we are counselors you know historically that's why we are called legal counsel uh ultimately uh I stand in in the shoes of the company I advise the company as a whole not pursuing or pushing one particular sort of strong voice
or lead actor as I call them and I advocate different scenarios, different individuals and ultimately they make the decision on whether they want to see uh see themselves through choppy waters or they are potentially uh risking uh the the ship. not not sailing anymore. So this is what I think is very important when you have legal council that is looking out for the company as a whole and pushing it forward in the best interest of the company. Not who is the higher biggest shareholder not who has the loudest voice in the company. And I'm sure my my colleagues here know it takes metal to do
that because it's not always the thing that people want to hear. But that is our role. And like I always tell some of my juniors, if they don't want our counsel, then it's okay. We will step away. But we are not going to mince our words uh or act uh inappropriately. As Jeremiah said, some I've seen some myself. um that's not pursuing the genuine interests of of the company as a whole. So that is not what we would do. We would say as hard as it is to hear, we would assert our advice regardless of whether it's uh popular or not. But if those are
facts, those are our true advice, then we will we will go on that. So I hope that answers re ra's questions on how one would approach uh uh uh certain scenarios without breaking up the entire uh board. Great perspective and and Jeremiah you you might have some perspectives to also share. No, I think Melanie summarized exactly how I feel about things. Um you know I don't mince my words. Um, which is why I'm just a small lawyer in a small firm. Should learn to shut up sometime. You got to edit that. Edit that out. Uh, Ivan, all this uh, you know, comments for himself. It's
true. It's true. Uh, the fact is, you know, unfortunately I have not learned to keep a lid on it. Uh, but yeah, I think good counsel is really important and not just legal counsel, right? Um there are a lot of other stakeholders involved in the business as Melody pointed out. You've got the shareholders, you've got the directors, you got the company secretary, right? These are people who have a front row seat to any brewing dispute and who would be in a position to move first and try and help diffuse any thing before it, you know, becomes an issue that that is bigger than it really
should be. Yeah. Yeah, it's a great point that all of us as professionals really should try to be part of the solution and uh give the right advice the even if it's unpopular. I mean any mediator, any judge uh anyone who does dispute resolution, alternative dispute resolution will tell you that you need to find the key to every different human being. Every solution has to be packaged in a different way. And to me that is what I call beyond legal advice. This not a black letter. Not not not what the contract says. Everyone knows what the contract says. How do we get a solution beyond
the contract that will survive? This business can survive beyond that. That is the question uh that we all have to answer. Yeah. And it's a noble goal and uh it it makes much more difference. Um, Mark, any final words on on this topic? I think I fully agree with what Melanie said. It really it there's need to not just say the right answer, but say at the right time, say it to the right person. Say it in a way that uh they'll be receptive to your message. Um, and that's that that really is an art and something I think uh my colleagues over here, season
legal council will be able to help with. um and to also actually just uh remind your client that really uh you don't have any I mean you don't have that kind of vested interest that they have in it and that's precisely why you can give the best and most objective advice uh that is suited for the situation. So I think really uh it takes time to be able to understand your client fully so they can deliver the solution to them in the correct packaging. Yeah. Yeah. There's huge value in an impartial third party and especially one with those superpowers that Mel Melanie mentioned of uh
persuasion and um unlocking people's uh objectives and goals. I just want to give Jeremiah and Melanie also a chance for any final words as well. Um anything you wanted to to add before we we wrap? Uh well, if I had to give just one last piece of advice, it ties in with Melanes and Mark's point, right? And that is be honest, right? Be honest at the start. You know, um try and figure out um early on what you really want out of that union. The more BS you spew at the start, the more gets flung back at you when it hits the fan. So be
honest and you know work out your arrangements, your tie downs early on because that's going to form the bedrock of your cooperation and partnership you know for the many years to come hopefully. Hopefully if not make sure you got Melanie Mark's number on speed dial you know I can't help you there. I wish you guys all the best. Uh but yeah, well a huge thank you to our to our panelists uh Melanie, Mark, Jeremiah, Ray for your time. Um I really appreciate you giving up the time. Sorry we we went a little bit over, but I really really appreciate it. We will be in touch
again around the recording and the edits and and clearing them by you. And if I can just remind you again that when we finish here, if you could just leave the the Riverside app, the the window open and let it you'll see a percentage uploading figure hopefully on your end and you'll see when it's 100% and you can close the window. But huge thank you again. We look forward to to partnering together going forward and uh really appreciate your contributions today. Thank you everybody. Thank you. Thank you. Bye.
What is the most common cause of startup failure?
The most-cited causes are running out of cash and building something with no real market need. In CB Insights’ analysis of startup post-mortems, running out of cash and lack of market need top the list, while problems with the founding team appear in a meaningful minority of cases. Founder and team conflict is therefore not usually the single biggest cause, but it is a leading contributor that is largely preventable.
How big a role do co-founder disputes play in startup failure?
Larger than many founders expect. CB Insights records “not the right team” in roughly 14–23% of failures, and Harvard Business School professor Noam Wasserman found that interpersonal “people problems” among the founding team drive the majority of failures in high-potential startups. The widely quoted “65%” figure is best understood as referring to these broader people problems rather than co-founder conflict alone.
What should a founders' agreement include?
At a minimum: share vesting and reverse vesting, good-leaver and bad-leaver provisions, a deadlock-breaking mechanism, drag-along and tag-along rights, reserved matters requiring super-majority approval, each founder’s roles and remuneration, intellectual-property assignment to the company, confidentiality and restrictive covenants, and a dispute-resolution clause. In Singapore these are contractual good practice rather than statutory requirements, so they should be tailored to your cap table.
What is shareholder oppression under Singapore law?
Under section 216 of the Companies Act 1967, a member may apply to the court where the company’s affairs are conducted, or directors’ powers exercised, in a manner that is oppressive, in disregard of the member’s interests, or unfairly discriminatory or otherwise prejudicial. The courts apply a test of “commercial unfairness.” The court has broad discretion, and the most common remedy is an order that one party buy out the other’s shares at a fair value.
How are founder disputes resolved in Singapore?
Most are best resolved through negotiation and mediation, via the Singapore Mediation Centre or Singapore International Mediation Centre, which is confidential, faster and preserves relationships. Where a binding private decision is needed and an arbitration clause exists, arbitration at SIAC is available. Court action is reserved for statutory remedies such as an oppression claim under section 216, a derivative action under section 216A, or a winding-up application.
Can a 50/50 deadlock force a company to wind up?
It can. A genuine, permanent deadlock between equal shareholders is a recognised basis for winding a company up on the “just and equitable” ground under section 125(1)(i) of the Insolvency, Restructuring and Dissolution Act 2018, and the Singapore Courts expressly cite management deadlock as an example. However, winding up is a remedy of last resort: if a less drastic option such as a share buy-out is available and the petitioner is acting unreasonably, the court may decline to order it. A deadlock-breaking clause in the founders’ agreement is the better safeguard.
Is a shareholders' agreement the same as the company constitution?
No. The constitution is the mandatory governing document every Singapore company files with ACRA; it is public and binds all members as a statutory contract, and amending it needs a 75% special resolution lodged within 14 days. A shareholders’/founders’ agreement is a separate, private contract that binds only its signatories and is not filed with ACRA. The two should be drafted to align, with sensitive commercial terms usually kept in the private agreement.
Since 20 October 2026, a Singapore company filing its ACRA annual return must confirm that the particulars of its directors, chief executive officers, secretaries, auditors…
An Employment Pass holder can own a Singapore company, but cannot work for it on the current pass. Here is what MOM allows, where the…
What to collect from your current transfer pricing adviser, the S$10 million documentation test, and how to meet the 30 November 2026 deadline.