ACRA Annual Return From 20 Oct 2026: Confirm Particulars, CEO Question
Since 20 October 2026, a Singapore company filing its ACRA annual return must confirm that the particulars of its directors, chief executive officers, secretaries, auditors…
Published: 18 June 2026 · Reviewed by Ray Tay, Co-Founder & Director, VIVOS PTE. LTD. (ACRA Filing Agent FA20240323 · MOM EA Licence 24S2425)
In Singapore, digital assets are regulated mainly by the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) under the Payment Services Act 2019, with crypto exchange and transfer services treated as “digital payment token” (DPT) services and held to anti-money-laundering, custody and consumer-protection rules. A separate Digital Token Service Provider (DTSP) licensing regime under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2022 took effect on 30 June 2025 for Singapore-based firms serving only overseas customers, a licence MAS says it will rarely grant. Singapore courts already recognise cryptocurrency and NFTs as property capable of being held on trust, so where assets are stolen the High Court can grant proprietary and worldwide freezing (Mareva) injunctions, plus disclosure orders against exchanges. When a dispute crosses borders, recovery is legally possible but practically difficult, depending on tracing the assets and enforcing orders in the jurisdiction where they sit.
| 0:00 | Introduction |
| 3:10 | Singapore regulatory framework |
| 7:30 | Structuring a crypto business |
| 14:00 | Cross-border & crypto as property |
| 21:00 | Security risks & scams |
| 27:30 | Anatomy of an attack |
| 34:00 | Freezing & recovering assets |
| 48:00 | Custody, insurance & risk |
| 1:00:00 | Asset recovery routes |
| 1:06:00 | Practical takeaways |
Singapore does not have a single “crypto law”. Instead, the regulatory treatment of a digital asset depends on what the asset does and what activity is carried on with it. The principal regulator is the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS), and the most common entry point is the Payment Services Act 2019 (PS Act), which regulates “digital payment token” (DPT) services such as dealing in, or facilitating the exchange of, cryptocurrencies. Firms providing these services must be licensed and comply with anti-money-laundering and countering-the-financing-of-terrorism (AML/CFT) obligations.
The framework has been tightened materially. On 2 April 2024 MAS amended the PS Act to expand the scope of regulated payment services and to impose new user-protection and financial-stability requirements on DPT service providers, with the changes taking effect in stages. Among other things, providers must segregate customers’ assets and hold them on trust, with those safeguarding requirements taking effect six months from 4 April 2024 (MAS, 2024).
MAS has also been deliberately restrictive towards retail speculation. Under its guidelines, DPT service providers should not promote their services to the general public in Singapore, should not offer incentives to trade, must not provide financing, margin or leverage to retail customers, cannot accept locally issued credit-card payments for crypto, and are restricted from facilitating lending or staking of tokens by retail customers (institutional and accredited investors are treated differently). These consumer-protection measures took effect on 4 October 2024 (MAS, 2023).
On 15 August 2023 MAS finalised a regulatory framework for single-currency stablecoins (SCS). It applies to SCS pegged to the Singapore Dollar or a G10 currency and issued in Singapore. Issuers must meet requirements on reserve-asset composition and valuation, redemption at par, capital and disclosure; only those that satisfy the full framework may apply to label their tokens as “MAS-regulated stablecoins” (MAS, 2023).
A distinct regime targets a narrower gap. From 30 June 2025, businesses or individuals operating from a place of business in Singapore, or incorporated in Singapore, that provide digital token services solely to customers outside Singapore must be licensed as Digital Token Service Providers (DTSPs) under Part 9 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2022. MAS has set the bar high and has stated it will generally not issue such a licence, because the money-laundering risk is elevated and it cannot effectively supervise activity carried on wholly overseas (MAS, 2025). Firms already serving customers in Singapore remain regulated under the PS Act, Securities and Futures Act 2001, or Financial Advisers Act 2001, as applicable.
The first question for any digital-asset venture is licence classification, because it drives everything else. The VIVOS panel emphasised mapping the proposed activity to the correct regime before incorporation: a token-exchange or transfer service typically falls under the PS Act as a DPT service; dealing in tokens that are capital-markets products engages the Securities and Futures Act; and a Singapore entity that serves only overseas users may fall into the DTSP net under the FSMA.
A common structuring trap is assuming that serving only foreign customers avoids Singapore regulation. The opposite can be true: that exact model is what the DTSP regime now captures, and MAS has signalled it will rarely license it. Founders should therefore decide early whether their customer base will include Singapore, and design substance, governance and AML/CFT controls to match the regime that applies. Capital is also a live consideration; MAS sets out base-capital requirements that an applicant must meet and maintain.
Because the regulatory perimeter shifts with the business model, structuring is best treated as a legal and tax exercise from day one rather than a compliance afterthought. VIVOS works with founders on entity selection, licensing strategy and the tax treatment of token issuance and trading.
Yes, under Singapore law, cryptocurrency and NFTs are recognised as property. In ByBit Fintech Ltd v Ho Kai Xin and others [2023] SGHC 199, the High Court held that crypto assets are property capable of being held on trust and are choses in action, applying the classic four-part test from National Provincial Bank v Ainsworth (the asset must be definable, identifiable by third parties, capable of assumption, and have some permanence). This built on earlier rulings: in CLM v CLN and others [2022] SGHC 46 the court treated stolen cryptocurrency as property capable of being the subject of a proprietary injunction, and in Janesh s/o Rajkumar v Unknown Person (“CHEFPIERRE”) [2022] SGHC 264 it recognised an NFT as property and granted a proprietary injunction over a Bored Ape Yacht Club token.
The property characterisation matters enormously for victims of theft and fraud, because it unlocks proprietary remedies and tracing. Later decisions have continued to refine the practicalities: courts have addressed how to value notoriously volatile crypto holdings and how jurisdiction is established in cross-border claims.
Cross-border friction is the recurring theme. A Singapore court can recognise your stolen tokens as property and freeze them, but the wallet, the exchange or the wrongdoer may sit in another country. Enforcement then turns on tracing the assets on-chain, identifying the holder, and obtaining recognition or co-operation in the relevant foreign jurisdiction, which is where many recoveries succeed or stall.
Most digital-asset losses are not failures of the blockchain itself but of the people and platforms around it. The VIVOS panel framed the dominant risk categories at a deliberately general, educational level: social-engineering and phishing that trick a holder into revealing access; compromise of private keys or recovery phrases; and counterparty failure, where an exchange or custodian becomes insolvent or is itself compromised. Investment “scams”, fake platforms, romance-investment fraud, and impersonation remain a large share of reported losses.
The scale is significant. According to the Singapore Police Force, victims lost about S$182 million to scams involving cryptocurrency in 2025, roughly a fifth of all scam losses that year, while a dedicated Crypto Tracing Team, operational since March 2025, has helped recover over S$20 million in virtual assets (Singapore Police Force). The practical lesson for businesses and individuals is that prevention, sound key management, verified counterparties and scepticism towards “guaranteed” returns are far cheaper than recovery.
Without giving any operational detail, the typical pattern the panel described is: an attacker first obtains access (often through deception rather than code), then moves assets quickly through a chain of wallets and across services to frustrate tracing, before attempting to cash out via an off-ramp. Because on-chain movement is fast and irreversible, the window to act is short, which is precisely why the freezing tools below are time-critical.
Singapore’s courts have a well-developed toolkit for preserving and recovering misappropriated digital assets, and crucially they can deploy it even where the wrongdoer is anonymous. In CLM v CLN the High Court granted Singapore’s first worldwide freezing (Mareva) injunction against “persons unknown” in a crypto-theft case, together with a proprietary injunction and disclosure orders against exchanges. The main tools are summarised below.
VIVOS video: Can Singapore Courts Recover Stolen Digital Assets? (1 October 2025), from the VIVOS round table on digital assets, regulation, security and cross-border disputes.
| Tool | What it does |
|---|---|
| Proprietary injunction | Preserves specific assets that the claimant asserts belong to them, preventing dealing or dissipation pending trial. |
| Worldwide freezing (Mareva) injunction | Restrains a defendant from dissipating assets, potentially on a worldwide basis, to keep them available to satisfy a judgment. |
| Bankers Trust / disclosure orders | Compel third parties such as exchanges to disclose account and transaction information to help identify wrongdoers and trace funds. |
| Service out of jurisdiction | Permits a claim and orders to be served on defendants located abroad where the case meets the jurisdictional gateways. |
| Service by alternative means | Allows service through non-traditional channels – in CHEFPIERRE, the court permitted service via the defendant’s social-media account and crypto wallet. |
Speed is everything. Because on-chain transfers are near-instant and irreversible, victims should seek injunctive relief and disclosure orders as early as possible, ideally before the assets are moved through mixing services or off-ramped into fiat.
For businesses holding client crypto, custody is now a regulated discipline, not a technical detail. Following the 2024 PS Act amendments, DPT service providers must segregate customers’ assets, hold them on trust, keep proper records and maintain systems to protect the integrity and security of those assets. The policy aim – sharpened by the failures of the 2022 “crypto winter” is to keep customer assets identifiable and ring-fenced from a provider’s own balance sheet, so they can be returned if the provider fails.
Custody choices (self-custody, qualified third-party custodian, or a mix), key-management architecture and insurance cover should be assessed together as part of an operational-risk framework. Insurance for digital-asset custody exists but is specialised, and cover for theft or key loss should be read carefully against its exclusions. The panel’s general guidance was to treat custody, governance and insurance as a single risk question rather than three separate procurement decisions.
When assets are lost, recovery usually runs along two complementary tracks. The civil route uses the proprietary and freezing injunctions and disclosure orders described above to preserve assets, identify holders, and ultimately obtain judgment and enforcement.
The criminal/regulatory route involves reporting to the police and relevant authorities, who can investigate, work with overseas counterparts and, increasingly, trace assets on-chain in Singapore, through a dedicated crypto-tracing capability that has recovered virtual assets in practice.
The realistic assessment the panel offered: recovery is possible and Singapore’s legal tools are among the most developed in the region, but outcomes depend on speed, the quality of on-chain tracing, whether the assets reach a co-operative exchange or jurisdiction, and the cost of cross-border enforcement. Some value is recovered; full recovery is far from guaranteed. Early, coordinated legal action materially improves the odds.
Planning a digital-asset venture, weighing a licensing strategy, or dealing with a cross-border dispute? VIVOS advises founders and businesses on structuring, licensing and risk. Speak with our corporate advisory team, or explore how token issuance and trading are handled under our taxation services.
Welcome to our VIVOS round table on digital assets, regulation, security and crossber challenges. It is complex. I mean even even the the starting point of trying to structure your business is already an academic exercise. The nature of crypto assets, the fact that it's easily traded or moved, you know, across jurisdictions and the fact that's anonymous. So that's something we need to be careful on. But why the crypto scams or fraud, you can say a lot more prevailent. Meet V. Kumar Sharma, partner at Elden Law, leading digital assets and cyber security. Next, we have Michael Louu, quantum security leader and co-founder of Aegis Digital Asia. At
last, we have Amelia Tan, councel at Kerry Olsen, expert in crossber disputes. Together, we're going to uncover the future of digital assets, regulation, and security. Good morning everyone and welcome today to our vivos roundt on all things digital assets from regulation security to what to do in those oh no moments. Today's conversation hopes to bring together three leaders who operate right at the intersection of law, technology and security. From regulatory structuring and asset recovery to cyber security, forensic intelligence and crossborder complex litigation, this panel has handled some of the most high stakes cases in the digital asset space. Let me briefly introduce our speakers. First,
Amelia Tan, council at Kerry Olson Singapore, specializing in litigation, fraud, asset tracing, and crossber insolveny. With deep experience across BBI, Cayman and Bermuda, she frequently advises on digital asset disputes, freezing orders, and complex recovery actions across jurisdictions. Second, V. Kumar Sharma, partner at Elden Law LLP, where he leads the digital assets, cyber security and emerging technologies practice. His work spans regulatory advisory, token structuring, commercial fraud, and recovery of misappropriate digital assets with recent recognition as a Singapore rising star by Asian legal business. Last but not least, Michael Louu is a seasoned expert in digital forensics, crypto investigations, and quantum security. He's the co-founder of Aegis
Digit Digital Asia and previously served as CEO of Raja Antan Technologies after his AIdriven legal tech startup was acquired. He's also a court recognized expert witness and chair of the blockchain association Singapore's digital enterprise subcommittee. Over the next hour, we'll explore where legal frameworks are adapting, where security blind spots still exist and how businesses, investors, and policy makers can better safeguard this fast-moving ecosystem. So, let's dive in starting with how the regulatory landscape is keeping pace with the rapid innovation we're seeing in tokenization, DeFi, and beyond. Thanks so much, R Ivan, for having us here today. I think this is a really important topic both
in terms of what can be done uh in this jurisdiction today and the challenges that faces everyone right that's trying to operate in in this industry. So I mean broad broadly speaking you know in Singapore we've had the securities and futures act and the primary question that arises out of that statute is whether or not the token that you are um or the service and token that you're providing amounts to a capital markets product whether or not it's a security token or utility token that's the primary threshold question Singapore has evolved couple of years ago 2019 we've now got we've got the payment services act
that regulates activity and the threshold question there is whether or not you know the token that you are dealing with broadly is a digital payment token and of course there there are questions around how how that's defined and recognized exceptions as well as to what is not a digital payment token that certain projects rely on to carry out their operations. Third and most recently we've we've seen this omnibus um regulation the FSMA Financial Services Market Act. I don't have the full name off the top of my head, but it's abbreviated as the FSME. And of course, there was there was this recent um concern when
MEES issued this 30-day deadline for businesses operating in Singapore to get a license if you're ser if you're providing a digital payment token services to customers outside of Singapore. So, if you've got a Singapore HQ and you're still providing services overseas, then you need a license, right? and if you don't have a license, you're not allowed to operate. So there's there was quite a fair bit of uh controversy there. And well, long story short, there are certain exceptions uh to that particular regulation as well that our clients have relied on. The primary one being that you are technical services provider, right? So there are two
threshold questions when it comes to whether or not you want to get licensed and you don't want to get licensed but still operate here. If you don't want to get licensed and still operate here, then first we could have arguments about how your services doesn't involve a digital payment token so that those regulations may not be triggered. But the second one and the one that uh I think it's the is the better one is to rely on the express exceptions and being a technical service provider is one of them. So how how we see businesses structured is that Singapore will be the technical services provider.
Maybe we'll park the intellectual property here. Funds may also be raised on the Singapore entity. At the same time, the actual token generating entity may be somewhere else, right? Usually the tokens are generated uh in an offshore jurisdiction. Millia will have plenty of u experience with that, no doubt. But we've also seen Abu Dhabi, the ADGM um DT Foundation, distributed ledger token foundation being a choice for some businesses. And I think the the value there is that in some instances it's an orphan entity. And when I say orphan entity, I mean that you can set out the beneficiaries and the bene you can have no
shareholders in that entity. So that gives businesses more ways to argue that there's no nexus between the Singapore entity and the Abu Dhabi entity, right? Because you can change control, you can have different management teams, the different owners. So there is that gap, right? And you can you can hedge your risk with contracts, etc. And of course, finally, in this structure, there will be a front-facing entity which actually carries out the service. And depending on the type of business you're doing and the jurisdiction in which you're doing it, you may need a license, but you may not need a license in Singapore, right? So, we've
seen front-facing, for example, uh, Dexes, decentralized exchanges seeking licenses out of the BVI, for example. So broadly speaking, that's how we see businesses structure themselves uh to meet their objectives. Whether or not they want a license, where they want to do it, and whether or not they want to stay in Singapore and still operate, you know, leverage on that um the resources and branding that comes with operating out of Singapore. But I think I think I shared quite a fair bit. A grateful for any thoughts you might have on on what you've seen in the space. Yeah, I mean, thanks for sharing that, Kuma. I
mean it's interesting to hear how Singapore has evolved in terms of catering to businesses who want to have some sort of presence here but also the crossborder element which is you know uh kind of synonymous with crypto assets and how you know um the the crypto crypto um uh you know the business is operated. So I think um um well I I can speak from an offshore perspective so you know in BVI and Cayman because it's what we do at Carrie Osen. Um and I think in terms of uh the regulatory framework in the offshore jurisdictions particularly BBI Cayman I think in terms of regulating
the digital u assets environment um you know fair bit of thought has gone into that um and in fact I think uh BVIN is one of the first few jurisdictions to have actually come together to put together some sort of uh framework as early on as uh in 2015 um to have consultations with the relevant players and And eventually that gave rise to um the virtual assets providers act or in short vaps which I'm sure you know you've you've you've you've heard a lot about um essentially what it is is uh you know it's is a framework that that aims to give uh you know
enough um uh control supervision of u virtual asset service providers and also uh sort of supervising all the activity that's going on in in that space. Um but of course that that being said you know um I I think the the framework is there to give a good sense of what is required in terms of licenses but at the same time it doesn't stifle um the aim is not to stifle sort of um uh you know crypto activities um you know be it u exchanges issuers and I think the the whole idea of BVI Cayman is really sort of to encourage um u players to
to continue to operate out and have certain businesses in BVI by Cayman and in fact um we'll touch on that I'm sure at a later part of the uh the the the the the session you you'll see actually you know when it comes to asset tracing and recovery of um um you know stolen tokens or uh tokens that have been misappropriated uh very often you do see an offshore entity there and uh you know we we have um been advising in terms of strategies and and ways that you know one could could help and uh to help recover this lost tokens And I think um
you know while while um you look at it a whole spectrum right from the start you know initial regulation to things you can do later on to help recover tokens I think um you know the offshore jurisdiction has has a good um uh framework in terms of uh legal protection from from start to the end. Thank you both. Uh really fascinating and if you think of all those different legal jurisdictions and the flow of funds and the the crossber nature, do you you know what what kind of legal challenges what kind of legal obstacles does the multi-jurisdiction the differences in legal treatment across the jurisdictions
pose? So someone wanting to get into this space, what kind of advice would you give them to keep it simple to to consider the legal risks and the legal considerations from the beginning? I think because you know I I actually I'm I hesitate because I can't think of a simple sort of like just do it one way and and um you're golden, you know, because it it is complex. I mean even even the starting point of trying to structure your business is really an academic sort of exercise you know you're trying to figure out what you're doing where you're operating from and more importantly how
you're going to raise value you know on on your business whether or not it's being done on the equity level or on the token level and how that's structured. So I'm sorry man I don't have a simple sort of do it out of Singapore and in your gold. The truth is that you have to constantly keep your eye on the ball because the laws are constantly changing. there there are constant challenges uh in this industry both in terms of how the industry is evolving. So we've got industry trends, right? We've got real world uh asset tokenization as as one of the next um things, next
streams that people are trying to build. And at the same time, you've got uh evolving regulations. So I I don't think that there's a simple unfortunately a simple solution. And my advice, and I'm sure Mill will agree with me, is that you have to keep your eye on the ball and constantly reassess uh your business both in terms of whether or not it's playing within the right boundaries and the steps you're taking to protect right protect your assets and and protect the business. Yeah, I agree with all of that. I think um you know the nature of crypto assets, the fact that it's easily traded
um or moved you know across jurisdictions and the fact that's anonymous um and it's done very quickly all these are are challenges uh if you're going to this space that's challenges that you have to deal with you have to grapple with um but you know like like uh like Kuma said um you know you just got to be aware uh on developments um and and know that um you know the the legal framework is also developing at the same time right to help you um be it regulations the outset or even asset tracing mechanisms things that you can do if something goes wrong but hopefully
we won't get there uh but yeah I mean it's it is it's it's as with every new industry there are challenges um it's sort of understanding the fundamentals the principles and understanding you know the the the the the system the ecosystem that you are you you're sort of dealing with. Okay. So it's sort of is constantly evolving. It's wise to keep up to date, get the latest advice, but it's also partly what you're trying to optimize for, right? What are your objectives? What are your goals? And then depending on that, there are good solutions. Um, you've both kind of touched on it a little bit,
but then what what what are the areas that you think Singapore plays a role or where is Singapore's strength in this uh in this architecture then or this this model? What what's what's Singapore good at? Singapore's primary strength is its reputation first of all in terms of being a uh a jurisdiction in which it's stable there's stability there's some level of certainty right with with how you can structure and operate here and I think that's of tremendous value um operating out of Singapore what was the second part of your question Ivan is was there anything else on it or just why Singapore was it yeah
you covered it well I think Uh, Amelia, what are your thoughts? I mean, I I I I I you know, um, obviously I'm I'm not I'm not one um to to best place on advice on what what Singapore is is doing. I mean, on a crypto front, I mean, I don't advice on Singapore laws, but from what I know, of course, Singapore is uh is is is is very competitive in terms of um sort of regulating regulations and also um encouraging um players to want to operate out of Singapore. Um and I think that's evident from you know you look at the big crypto exchanges
that have um issues or or rather the you know big big players have gone into um the ones that you hear about more commonly right like 3ac uh you know um and all of that that there is a Singapore element. So by by by that on its own you could tell that you know Singapore has u sort of already managed to to to to um you know attract u very big volume high value um sort of uh uh crypto um businesses to operate out of out of uh Singapore. And I think the fact that we have seen you know disputes early on just shows that
um you know Singapore can only get better in terms of sort of uh strengthening the framework improving the the the the sort of um you know the regulatory environment too between the the experts here. What are your thoughts in terms of the different strengths and weaknesses of the the legal jurisdictions and you know the major locations that are are active in this space globally at the moment. Um Amelia, would you like to to share anything? You've got a good perspective across some of the key key locations. Yeah. Um I I think in terms of you know the jurisdictions that I deal with um so offshore
jurisdictions BVI came in um it helps that the courts there, the regulators there are very used to dealing with um not a lot of information about end users. um you know um it's it's only um um a very recent uh you know or not not that recent but I mean a couple of years ago where um you know information on directors are publicly searchable for for BBIN companies. So um regulators, courts um are well equipped to deal with um these sort of issues which we now see in crypto assets where you know this uh anonymous you know transacting of uh of of of um in
terms of transactions um not knowing who are you know the holders of you know private keys uh wallets that have you know no owners. Uh so so things like that are are are I think um issues that um are not new to offshore courts. Obviously uh in terms of you know the the kind of um assets you're dealing with is a different nature is a newer uh class of assets but I think general principle wise um you will see a lot of similarities in terms how the legal framework are used or adapted to help in asset tracing um efforts. So from that perspective, I think
u you know the offshore jurisdictions has um sort of um uh a good um a good head start in the sense that it's it's not something new. It's something they've been grappling all time. Um, in fact, you know, the the courts have always been sort of um at the forefront of dealing with um not so clear issues of laws and they're not they're not shy of um pushing boundaries and and and making um sort of new decisions um uh if if they have to. And I think we we see that in a couple of uh crypto decisions where you know um I think shortly after
the UK decision where an injunction was granted against persons unknown um the judgment was also in the BBI um to that similar effect. So you know things are moving very quickly I would say in in in in BBI keeping up um to help uh in in asset recovery efforts for for for stolen or or misappropriated crypto assets. And Kumar your thank you Amelia Kumar your thoughts. Well I think it's established that cryptocurrencies are property right and now we've got cases talking about what type of property and the type of property uh that a crypto asset is has a bearing on how you build in protections
at the start. So I'll give you an example right in in there's a high court decision right now uh which observes that crypto assets are a chosen action what does that mean what does that mean right a chosen action is a right that you have that you can use in court it's not something physical it's something that the court recognizes as valid and can be protected think of your right as a shareholder your right to a debt in a contract that sort of incorporal right is what a crypto asset currently is characterized at uh as in Singapore in the UK there's a slightly different approach
in the UK there's a there's a judicial task force that has proposed a third category of object called digital objects and the primary question there is of control who controls that object now I I personally this is my personal view I actually like the UK characterization a little bit more because it it gives it gives clarity on two aspects If I call it, if I call this asset a digital object and I give that asset away, let's say I give some to a market maker, how do I retain control? I can argue that it's being held on trust. So if anything happens to that third
party, it it goes insolvent. It's still your asset. The second is retention of title. There are all these concepts about traditional commodities trading that could apply to crypto assets if they are characterized as digital objects that would apply. So notwithstanding who possesses the object as long as title is yours, it's your asset, right? So th those are the types of things that I actually want to see and and I try to to build into contracts when people are dealing with assets and lending them out whether or not uh you you retain title assuming of course the law recognizes it as an object. and second uh
holding it on trust. Those are two common areas. But yeah, that just that's where we're at, right? What type of object? The next part of this conversation will be taking security over that object. So you've got all these charges, pleasures, all these old uh not old but in traditional industries, you've got other ways of taking security over assets that will start to apply and has already begun applying to crypto assets and we'll start seeing more of that as the industry evolves. Michael, thank you Kumar. Michael, what are your thoughts? Um, yeah, so I I want to talk about um sort of KYC, right? Know your
customer. So in that sense, I think that has evolved as well. Uh because traditionally the customer of a digital asset is usually an individual, you know, so even you're talking about startups, you know, is still an individual holding a wallet, you know, but we have seen a a change. there's a lot of institutional uh purchaser as well. So when it comes to corporation even list co uh sort of accumulating uh crypto asset right so when it comes to organization uh then it will be a different safeguard because it will not be helped by uh the CEO or individual you know so there are policies and
procedures there's also third party uh service providers like c custody uh services so I think that is a major shift that we are seeing and that also means that uh the industry uh is evol evolving, you know, so once you get the sort of commercial or corporate clients in, uh, definitely is it is a good sign that is heading um more commercialized direction. Thank you, Michael. Um, and you we we touched a little bit earlier on things like tokenization of real world assets and uh the different types of use cases. So just curious from from the three of yourselves active in this space, what are
the kind of emerging types of crypto securities, cryptos assets, crypto projects that you see um taking off particularly in relation to to Singapore and and and this market here. Yeah, may maybe I'll start first. I think uh in the recent sort of uh months I think there is a big move to use of stable coin uh because thesis of using s of crypto asset has been quite sound. Uh so but of course the problem with crypto assets such as bitcoin or ethereum you know it does fluctuate you know so but again in a commercial aspect you know if the adoption from corporate so they will
want something which is a bit more stable. So in in that sense the use of stable coin for their commercial purposes will be much welcome. How about the rest? What do you think? Well I can't speak for Singapore specific projects. I mean I know that there are D5 projects some DEX one DEX is operating in a sandbox but I can say that as a trend right there that's agentic AI. So the intersection between AI and blockchain, right? The sort of projects where you own a piece of the AI and you're able to trade it on chain, that sort of project. We've seen some of that.
We've also seen um securities related um tokenization of securities. So we've seen projects that try to partner up with registered securities brokers and design that entire onboarding and payouts for bonds for example uh onchain. So we've seen a few projects trying to to put your securities investments on chain. I could put it that way right and how do you go about structuring that? Um those are the two two big trends that we've personally observed. How about you, Amelia? How about your end? Yeah, I mean um I think broadly um speaking they kind of mirror what um I think both you and um uh Michael have
have been been saying, but I think um there also other things like sort of you know uses of um digital assets um in which uh how we can encourage u you know more prevalent use of it. So um like you said you know sec securityization of that is a big one. um the use of it in in in sort of um payment for services I think as well in terms of offshore jurisdictions that is something that's has come out uh in in recent um recent years for discussion I don't think it's Cayman BI specific I think it's what is happening generally across you know jurisdictions
and markets how about another type of trend uh trend trends about scams and frauds and illegal activities you know what do what do you guys see in the market right now? What's the what the what's the latest trend in terms of scams and fraud for digital assets? Yeah, that that's a very interesting topic for me because I do see a lot of sort of scams and fraud uh around crypto asset. So, but the observation is is nothing new, you know, it's it's all about greed, you know, it's all about the positioning. So, scam remains scam, you know. So what has what is different is because
there's a huge interest in digital asset especially in bitcoin and some of the other performing digital currency you know so they're using it as a leverage you know so uh again it rides on great you know so to to make quick quick money you know with very little effort so that's something we need to be careful on but why the crypto scams or fraud are you can say a lot more prevailent is because a lot of people don't understand that is not like your fiat currency. Yes, in fiat you will still have to have a bank account. There's financial institution. Uh they're all regulated. So
you can trace back who you sent the money to, right? But when it comes to digital asset, you know, with just a crypto account, uh that's very very difficult to trace uh where it comes from and where it's going, you know? So that that's something you need to understand. And again to safeguard your own digital wallet uh it is also very difficult if you're not savvy enough even the more savvy uh sort of cyber security professionals like we do struggle as well because there's a lot of hack I mean there's a lot of cyber threat out there you know that even the larger organization sometimes
they felt there's a challenge so so the little guys like us you know we try our best you know but there is you need a lot of safeguard if you're putting all your eggs in one basket uh in this case is So digital wallet then you need to know how to protect it you know. Yeah. Yeah. Kumar. So this this topic uh you know I all three of us here is very close to us because you know we see that we see the effect we experience the effect vicariously of all these of of everyone who suffered these losses and we find it out. I mean
I'm I'm always upset whenever I see someone get a loss and we try our best to get a remedy. But in any event, back to the question, right? I think the majority of cases start with social engineering and fishing attacks. I've seen statistics about 50 to 60% of the attacks in the industry, right? It's is an attempt to socially engineer uh you from from basically departing a possession of your assets from yourself, right? And the trend I see is that it's it starts off well we've we've had fishing attacks in the past where funds are misdirected. So forget about crypto for a second. All these
older industries where payment instructions are intercepted. So you're supposed to make payment a third party impersonates uh the the seller. Payment is made to the third party threat actor instead of the seller. Right? And that entire compromise usually happens on email. Your email inboxes are compromised. Email forwarding rules are set up. And then you have to deal with the effect of having to pay twice. Once to the hacker, once to the actual person who's entitled to payment. Then we've sh seen a shift to more hacks on crypto assets. But a large majority of it also starts in some to some extent, right? with the same
type of fishing attack where you gain access your monitoring systems and then you are able to execute either a brute force attack or social engineering attack on these assets. And the third large trend is ransomware ransomware attacks right where you are you're locked out of your systems and then the question becomes do you pay or not? And once you pay if that payment is made in crypto then you have to start um hunting down the crypto. But I think that broadly speaking when you're faced with an attack you've got two options broadly right the first is you go after the hacker you can trace the
you trace your asset go get your court relief try and trace it to a centralized exchange etc but there's another that there's another approach right which is you identify the intermediaries so all of the third parties in between that contributed to your loss those parties should also fork up a percentage 30% 40% of your loss should be attributed to them. For example, so so for instance if you've got if you were lost be you suffer a loss because you downloaded an app from a crypto trading app and because of a compromise of their systems you know you led to loss those guys are a target
as well because you wouldn't have suffered a loss but for them. So big a big part of what at least we are trying to do is build out this capability to go after the intermediaries whether or not they're trading parties centralized exchanges we've had some success negotiating with them as well and the more challenging one decentralized exchanges um that's another those are targets and I've got thoughts we can talk about this all day right the third one broadly before I I hand the mic over to Amelia the third one is what I like to call a burn and remint remedy. So imagine someone takes your
your asset, you lose it, you call up the person who gave you the asset in the first place. That issuer in some instances can destroy the asset and give it back to you. Can destroy the asset in the hacker's wallet and just reissue it to you. A one for one exchange. So in my view, that must be the starting point in the entire analysis, right? If you suffer a loss, you should be able to go to the issuer and say if your if your timing is right, if the right set of circumstances, do a one for one exchange. And we we are seeing that now.
I' I've identified at least three or four uh entities in public SEC listings which give investors this right to burn and rem. So you're slowly seeing this being adopted and what we need is we need this as a as an industry standard in my view. Yeah, I've got other thoughts as well, but I' I'd like to give Amelia a chance to speak too. Yeah. No, I I think that's very interesting to hear and especially in relation to what you you you you said about the uh burn and re reissuance uh sort of mechanism. Um I think that's not new because um actually uh in in
in in the very early days uh you know when crypto fraud, crypto um you know misappropriation just became the hot topic. Um in fact that's what we've been doing with uh VVI issuers. Um some very often um you know these investors could be your your mom and pops right so they are not very sophisticated. They may not want to spend a lot of money to trace complicated you know tra tracing exercise. Um so they come to us and they'll be like oh you know um I have a this this issue um my my my my crypto assets have been misappropriated. Or it could be that
they simply loses control uh lost control over their their wallets. um they they can't they just can't log in or or for some reason they they can't access their their their assets. No. Um of course then what we have done is we have gone to these um issuers and say look this is an issue um you know something has happened there can you please reissue um tokens and they they they actually surprisingly I mean back then you know there's a lot of uncertainty as what it could do but that was an option that that they actually were were agreeable to and it happened pretty readily
to a couple of issuers. So I I certainly do agree with Kuma that that is a convenient starting point, right? If they could simply um as a matter of of of practical ways of dealing it in terms of burning it um you know and and just reissuing it, then then that that that could be a cure to a lot of you know your very um uh you know uh I would say um your average crypto investor who may have um sort of misappropriated lost assets or or or you know got scammed in one way or the other. But of course you're talking about high value
fraud. That's another question. Um and that of course uh requires you know a lot of technical expertise, a lot of tracing um a lot of uh finding out information as to you know how the transaction has has evolved you know from along along the the whole you know the whole blockchain what has happened when it's gone past uh the exchange you know and um and and and that's something that um I think we we've seen um in in in the offshore jurisdictions as well. uh the hacks happen at the exchanges. It hacks the hacks has also occurred at um the smart smart contract um you
know um um stage where you know the the it sort of causes the the the payments to be transferred to someone else instead. So um yeah I I would say it it happens in all shapes and forms and and I think it's just going to keep evolving as well. That's fascinating. Um you know we I mean there's no law, right? I mean it's all goodwill at the moment. Yeah. Yes. Yeah. So I I would like to add actually to summarize. So in the event let's say there's a fraud incident or it's a cyber attack you know or even scam you know there's actually two recourse
right. So the first recourse is go after the perpetrator right. So if there's a hacker or scammer you know we'll try to go after that but then that becomes criminal. So ob obviously you will have to involve the law enforcement to some capacity. So of course that's one track but then I also hear from Kuman Amelia there's a second track right the second track is to work with the institutional you know because there are people involved as well they are exchangers you know they are the uh the issuers so work with them to see how you can sort of stop uh the the transfer because
again digital asset has its pro and cons. So the pro of it is not like physical cash you know once cash is flowed out it's very difficult to get back you know but in this case it's still on the blockchain so you work with the right institution the right parties you could uh sort of put it what you call a no- win situation you know the hackers could have taken your crypto but they can't use it you know it could be frozen or it could be reissue so there's a recourse that you know in this circumstances of digital asset that we should always consider you
know besides just going after the perpetrator Yeah. Yeah. This is very practical, helpful advice. And we talked about the different use cases and I'm sure you know Singapore is a massive asset management market, a massive wealth market. I'm sure there are more and more family offices, asset managers, investors out there who have will have exposure will be holding digital assets and you know they will face these these these challenges at some point possibly. So um these three paths or these two paths that you shared that what what would be the practical advice hour one minute one when you feel oh my god have I have
I lost control have I have my assets been misappropriated as experts what would be your your minute one hour one action plan what would you recommend somebody to do uh evidence preservation is the first uh point of call so you need to keep lots your Google Chrome web history actually sets out a useful chronology of what how the attack broke out, where you went to, etc. Your email locks. Basically, the first point of call is retain evidence. That's very important because, you know, we've seen instances where businesses, they've got these automatic overriding uh rules in their inbox and then you lose evidence after four months
or six months depending on how it's set up and that may not be helpful. So I would say that's that's the first part of call. Uh the second part of call of course is to is to call us really because at the end of the day you need to go to the police or you need to if the police gives you enough information to say okay you know you've got some assets in these exchanges then it might make sense for you to freeze right get a freezing order freeze those assets and then the price your assets down so that you get some recovery. Some recovery
is better than no recovery. Okay. And sometimes the economics of the situation it makes sense for you to say okay you know I'll spend I'll I'll allocate this amount of resources try and get that back right um and of course you can continue exploring how the attack broke out. So a key question that we always ask ourselves is how does the threat actor know that you are a target? How does this actor know that your email address has got $4 million in a wallet on an exchange? Right? And in our in our experience, it's either friends and family. Someone in your network told this is
a person who who initiated the attack. Second, your devices are compromised probably from some other from some other platform. Well, the third one and one that we've relied on uh successfully is a data breach. There are some data breaches that that your information is out there. If it originated from an exchange for example then you might have legs to pressure or or negotiate with the exchange say hey you know this wouldn't have happened this entire series of events wouldn't have happened and uh but fall for that breach and so you know we should share that risk it's about allocating that risk of that of that
hack at the end of the day. So yeah, to sum it up, um, preserve evidence and get in touch with the police and and ask the experts to see whether or not we can at least get something back. Very interesting. I think not everybody would think of that preserving evidence aspect of it. Um, and it's it's good to hear that there are examples where people can get funds back. So maybe we go into some some uh case studies later, but Amelia, what would your advice be um at that moment? Yeah, I mean um you know I think I think both Kuma and I are litigators
and we're litigators the first the first instinct that that comes to you would be like you know pause right just uh uh uh don't do anything further you know keep whatever evidence you have preserve it um browser that's obviously the the key starting point um you know um um just making sure you don't tamper with any evidence um keep it you know um uh your your your search history and and all that. That's going to be quite quite key. Um then of course, you know, it's it's really sort of um a race against time, right? Um and and how quickly you think um you want
to basically steps that you have to take to really try to to freeze assets. Of course, there is a costbenefit analysis, you know, how much we're talking about um and you know, what what are some of the the the the options available to you. So, I think speak with an adviser. Um it could be a uh it could be you know a technical adviser that we tell you like how you can actually practically go around tracing it or a legal advisor in which um you know we we could tell you about what your your immediate options are in terms of freezing. If you're not if
not clear um it's not you know apparent to you who these third parties are. you know, we could get um knowledge pharmarmacical orders um you know, against um um against exchanges or issuers who may then be able to give you some information. you know, it could be KYC information about um certain people that have access your wallet or you know um and that might give you um that might give you some inkling as to um you know who may have have uh you know been involved uh and and so you could know actually who to go against and and that's that's obviously the the the
next stage in terms of framing your course of action, how to pursue and whether the the the the target um you know defend defendants or or respondents to any claim, you know, can can they actually is that is that actually going to be any practical recovery if you were to commence any action? So, there's a couple of steps there and advised to get good advice as soon as possible. Yeah. Can can I also add you know I think of course I agree with uh Amelia and Kuma data preservation is the key you know but I think whenever there's an instant right don't make it a
tech issue you know it has to be a management issue you know because I I've seen many cases that the tech team took over because it's a cyber issue it's a cyber attack to certain extent and then a knee-jerk reaction is they in in order to stop uh further spread you know they will delete everything you know or they'll turn up they get out of the system you So that's a very natural thought you know but once you do that actually you lose the linkage you lose some very precious evidence uh to trace back you know so it has to escalate to the top the
management even the legal and compliance of the company while they're not tech people but they know how to manage they know to engage expert you know and and also the I think the idea of data preservation is not something that I suppose the tech team are familiar with whereas on the legal and compliance or senior management they understand uh what that means you know, so that should always be the first step. Don't make it a tech issue, but more of a management decision on how to handle it. So, they have to take over. Interesting, Michael. And and in your experience, you know, that that would
be a tough decision to make if you have your your lawyers telling you to preserve everything and your IT team telling you to delete everything. Is it your experience that the IT team are, you know, it's wise to listen to your lawyers or or or how would you weigh those up? It is a balance there that that's the beauty of it like there there isn't a cookie cutter answer you know so to a certain extent both are right and both are wrong right so that's why engage experts study the situation you know and then see what works for the organization okay in short it's not
so simple right because it really depends you know of course just to give a quick example because uh in some instant maybe a company has very good BCP business continuity plan right so they a lot of good backups and all those then you can pursue a more aggressive approach you know to delete to to sort of cut but if you don't have a backup and then once you start deleting stuff you know you'll never be able to recover the crucial information that your business need to survive on okay so it's another consideration a a point you sort of touched upon Amelia I think everyone mentioned
you know the economics of it or the costbenefit analysis for an investor considering this and you know what are the kind of sums where it starts to be cost effective to to to deploy this kind of forensic approach this litigation approach these injunction approach at what point is the size of the asset usually sufficient that you're going to see a return on that kind of investment I think it's hard to give you a number uh and ultimately it is for you to assess right I mean it could be the very first it could be that maybe this is the very your first your first fraud
case um you know the value is not high but um maybe because for example your your your wallet you know or whatever is compromised so there could be u further recurrence of um um you know hacks into into your your your wallets and uh you know and and all of that so you might want to get to the bottom of it even though the first incident may not be of substantial value so I would say it's hard to put a monetary value to it um but of course you know um uh that there will be fees involved in obviously um getting uh legal advice, getting
technical experts in to to help you with the factf finding. And I think um in courts these days, they actually do want to see some sort of u um you know, depending on what the course of action is, they might ask for for for expert uh reports as well, you know, to to trace uh the the the the movement of the the the the crypto assets. So, just got to bear all these in mind. Um, but I I would say um I I mean I don't know Kumar may correct me if I'm wrong, but I think um I I I I think it's really hard
to place a value to it, but I think you can expect if you were to take take legal action, you know, that would cost you um you know, at least um at the very least, you know, u uh thousands of dollars even if analysis. So, of course, you're talking about really small sum uh then, you know, you you may or may not want to do it. you may want just to approach um the issuer and asking them to reissue the tokens to you. I mean, it's a self-help remedy. There's no harm in doing that, right? Um um but but of course, you're talking about a
huge um u sum and issue, then I would say uh get some legal advice. You may not need to go all the all the way, but at least um you know, you you kind of know what your options are. Yeah. Yeah. If I could quickly chime in before Kuma, I'm sure Kuma has a lot to share on this topic. Uh in my experience a lot of time is not just the value of uh the the incident is a lot on the reputation as well. So the reputation risk and then also uh business disruption because there are some case that you know it actually disrupt the
business. You have uh government contractors who refuse to work with you until they are certain that it's safe. So can you imagine the seerity of the disruption? Thank you, Michael. Thank you, Amelia. I mean, my my thoughts are that, you know, this economics idea is actually part of the tech. You know, death by a thousand cuts seen it so often that the the the claim the values that are being misappropriated are deliberately small. So, you'll see pe you see certain threat actors deliberately taking small amounts so that the economics doesn't stack up against them and you can't pursue them. That's a very common tactic and
how to deal with that uh sort of approach is to raise a class action right so there's some instances where victims can band together if you're all part of the same uh scenario and pull resources to try and get recovery that's how you deal with uh death by a thousand cuts right uh in my view the second one I of course echo Amelia's um sentiments in terms of cost but but my advice would be to spend that cost upfront on prevention. Right? So instead of of spending it on your legal advisor later, there are two things that you could do. The first is don't self-custody.
Go to a professional custodian with write an institutional custodian can hold your treasury and your assets for you. That's certainly something that you know businesses must explore as the first line of defense. The second one is insurance, cyber insurance for theft and if necessary professional uh indemnity insurance, right? So most custodians already have that insurance but you can must also explore whether or not you are entitled to it and can get uh insurance for your assets. Of course an an inadvertent side effect of having of all all these players uh around dealing with your assets is that touch would if one day something happens to
your assets you have more people to look to for recovery because you have intermediaries who've got a role to play in protecting your asset as well. Right? So that's definitely part of the equation. It's very interesting how the the conversation is evolving, right? So So you're not prescribing to the not your wallet, not your crypto kind of uh perspective on things that trust nobody, control everything yourself. You think the market is evolving now with the larger quantum, larger values that you institutional players can be trusted to to be your custodians and they're more likely to have the firepower, the resources to be able to protect
you, give you recourse or or or go after the threat actor. So in that sense, it's mirroring the traditional finance uh industry in a way. Yeah. I mean on just one last quick point on that the term mirroring. So now some digital asset custodians allow you to park your assets with them and also mirror it for example on exchanges so that you are actually trading a mirrored asset. So you save you protect your asset but you can still carry out business functions. That's certainly something that businesses have to explore you know as as your frontline defense against all of these attacks. Michael go on continue.
Yeah, I think this echo what I shared earlier on because we see that a lot of times the customer here are organization or institution, right? So it's no longer just an individual holding a crypto wallet. So there's a lot more options when you are when you're organization, you know, and you mentioned uh you know Kumar the the importance of of you know preemptive protection rather than uh afterwards. So what advice from a legal perspective other than you know using a institutional custodian is there other things that can be done to protect you from absolutely absolutely the starting point is your contracts with all third parties
how do you allocate risk for your cyber attack where does the list fall are you going to characterize it as a false major event some people might right and then the chips lie where they fall or do you allocate risk such that you know both of you share 50/50 if something happens So at least then you don't you don't suffer the full brunt of an attack. So the the starting point of course apart from introducing third parties to protect asset is your is your relationships with everyone else in your business in the event there's an attack how is that affected and is that built into
your contract? That's certainly something that everyone should think about and and incorporate in their contracts. Yeah. Yeah, and I think on on that, you know, just to add on as well, I mean, we're talking about frauds here, but I mean, al contracts are also important in the sense that you want to be clear or you want to have some clarity in terms of how your assets are actually being held uh by the third parties, you know, are they are they, you know, allowed to trade on your behalf? Um, are they comingling your assets with others or is it held in separate accounts? um you know
is it is it a segregated you know uh wallet or account and stuff like that because that would affect the legal categorization um in the event there any um asset tracing efforts or even where you know u touch root there's a some sort of insolveny event right are you going to end up uh being just a general class of creditors um in which case there could be you know millions right of of of people who are in the same position as you or do you want to make sure that you know you are you elevated to that of maybe um sort of um having some
sort of proprietary interest i.e. you know it's you it's assets are held on trust for you so it's some sort of property rights to it um so that that is also important and that I think um ties in with what Kuma is saying about pay attention to your contracts in the first instance because that's really the the first part of call in terms of how risk is allocated between the parties I'd like to kind of uh to to to keep it in a in a positive tone as well and to think of the the goods and the the uplifting um side of things rather than
the threats. Any any good positive examples of recovery or prevention um case studies or examples that you could share on a no-name basis that would give people um you know positive view on what's possible in this space that that they shouldn't just throw up their hands. I sometimes worry that the the the threat actors have been emboldened by a sort of an attitude that nothing can be done. The police won't do anything. The courts won't act for you. um you don't you know you're it's all all on the investors um risk on their shoulders and and that they're powerless when something happens but I'm sure
that's not the case from the the conversation today. So let's spread the word on on on what is possible and and the good outcomes that can result from that. Absolutely. Uh I gra I mean two come to mind right the the first is last year token 2049 uh there was a impersonation scam on so someone impersonated an event uh they got people to sign up and it looked legitimate you know because you get emails from so you cannot detect that it's a scam because it's from a legitimate source and so there were victims who went up got prompts from the threat actor saying um you
need to mint an NFT if not you'll be turned away at the for right one one hour away before the event right so there's this false sense of urgency we want to attend the event all these good people are there so there there was one particular victim who connected the wallet minted an NFD and it was a cold wallet and he was prompted to enable blind signing on the wallet what this means is that if you enable blind signing you cannot see where you cannot see all of the the the transaction you can't see the end point but you enable it anywhere It's a you
enable it anyway. And so blind signing is actually a common not not common but a known vulnerability in cold wallets. So you might think that your assets are safe but if you're tricked into blind signing you're not right. So this this happened tricked into blind signing wallets drained. Uh a couple of million tokens lost right for a particular for for a particular project. We managed to get it back because we the victim had a good relationship with the asset issuer. So within the span of about 20 minutes uh a decision was put to the DAO on whether or not to initiate a burn on the
tokens and the tokens were burnt and then we were we entered into a conversation over a few few months actually on whether or not the issuer could give it back and ultimately the issuer gave it back right which is why both A and I think are saying this must be the starting point she burn and reassurance must be starting point there must be loss for it that that's the first clear instance the second one Um, it's a method that both Michael and I actually worked on recently. We had a crypto trader who got a prompt on his phone saying someone is trying to login from
the Netherlands, right? He went to change his email password both on his personal email and the one associated with an exchange because he had he had assets parked on an exchange, very large exchange. He thought everything was safe. He's once you change your password, there's a 24-hour halt on withdrawals. So, you think, "Oh, no one can withdraw your assets." So you go to sleep. He went to sleep. He woke up about 3 to four million USD gone from his wallet. And it turns out the manner in which uh it his exchange accounts were compromised were that the hacker used three other accounts on the exchange
entered into trades right on both sides of the transaction and siphon monies out that way. So in this case um the exchange had a part to play unfortunately in how this victim lost his assets. But the problem is that you know when you sign up for uh for an account on exchange the the the entire terms and conditions are stacked against you. You know there risk disclosures you know you're responsible for all of your trades etc. But this particular terms and conditions were governed by Hong Kong law. And in Hong Kong there's a statute. I mean, this is not legal advice. Of course, you know,
I'm not afraid to adise in Hong Kong law, but there is a statute called the Hong Kong Unconable Contracts Ordinance, which states that, you know, in certain instances, if it's so unconsionable or unfair, the court can rewrite the contract or rewrite parts of it. So, we we basically we put up a claims notice. We didn't have to send it in the end, but we put it up anyway, right? that this is a textbook example of a contract that's so unconscionable and unfair. It surely amounts to the level you need to rewrite certain parts of it, right? And once you rewrite that, then there's case law,
Canadian case law, right? There there's no case law in Singapore or Hong Kong to my knowledge, but I've used Canadian case law in the past successfully to allocate risk. So if if some other uh counterparty systems are compromised and that led to the loss, then you should bear part of the loss. So right once you get rid of that uphill battle you can imply terms into the contract to shift liability to the exchange right that's one big part of it the second one is and I've talked about this earlier um how did the threat actor know to target this exchange or this email and we
we went with we went with a data breach uh on the end of the exchange because there were there was enough noise in the industry about a potential data breach and so our client and in an amical manner made all these points to the exchange right like look this happened it couldn't have this loss would have happened but for your accounts being compromised there may have been a data breach if necessary I'll have no choice but to pursue that and there was a third third um point as well which is that this exchange had a fins consent order in the US which which obliged them
to put a monitor in for 5 years to monitor their systems their transaction monitoring systems So we said I'm sure the monitor would like to know why it is that three other accounts are compromised. How are they compromised that that led to this? Right? So we had a big enough stick but we also had a carrot as well. And the carrot in this case was the fact that our client wanted to continue holding his assets with their exchange. So both both sort of all these factors together led to about uh 30 to 40% back without having to resort to legal proceedings. Right? So I think
you know that's that's a matter that Michael and I were were fortunate enough to sort of put together and work with and it's it's not it's not everything but it's something it's definitely something. Yeah. Yeah. I I I would like to add and uh Amelia could chip in but uh I think we talked a bit about the legal side of things. So I think in terms of the more positive aspect is actually on the technical side of things as well. You know while just now we heard about blindsiding like I say there is a danger if you don't know what you're dealing with when it
comes to technology especially dealing with crypto asset but there is also the upside right because there's a lot more control because if you know the technology you know it inside out you can really there's a lot more control than your traditional trusting the financial institution right because there's not a lot of transparency of what goes on in the financial institution and for good reason right because it's regulated But on the technology side like what Kumar say we are able to find out on what has happened how it happened you know because there's a lot of transparency on the blockchain you know so if you know
how to access this information it can be used on a very positive note in terms of recovering your your loss asset as well you know by a third party so we're not a bank but we can find the information uh because it's on the blockchain most of it right interesting so the technology can be used for defense as well was used against you. Exactly. And it's a lot more transparent. Millia. Yeah. Yeah, I mean um I think um you know um Kuma and Michael has has touched on you know a couple of examples and I think what I wanted to share is also um don't
don't think that you know just because um you know hackers are anonymous on the blockchain there's no way you know you could actually try to trace or get information or get KYC information like what Michael said uh because there are actually digital footprints that you can obtain uh and in fact uh I think I think there's one BBI case uh a couple of years ago uh called chain swap where um injunction was obtained against persons unknown um and they they ultimately they were hackers that hacked onto a sort of a blockchain um system where um crypto assets were diverted to other accounts and then ultimately
applied for other purposes misapplied for other purposes. Um and the end wallet where these um misappropriated uh crypto assets were were held in was uh you know with with assistance of some uh forensic uh folks. They could trace it to a wallet in Croatia and therefore uh they could obtain letter of request uh to the courts in Croatia to ask for u information about uh the holders of these wallets etc. So there are things that you can do um in terms of getting information about these third parties um you know and and and issuing uh mechanisms such like knowledge phical orders, bankers trust orders to
trace um you know where where the assets have gone and to to to at least obtain some recoveries or uh you know at least make sure that you know there's no further um loss cost to your your your your wallets and your accounts. Thank you Amelia. Well, I know that for for our clients and and the people that we advise, this can be a a scary and unfamiliar space, but uh today I think we shared some positivity and um hope and encouragement that there are options and actually that you know the technology, the laws, the the the processes can be used in your favor and
and it's not as a as as a lonely or challenging space as you might think. But of course the advice is is get it get in touch with the experts and the specialists as soon as possible and and to leverage that experience and and there are good examples and good recovery that can come from that. Um just leave it open for any final comments or thoughts um from from anyone here if there are any. Yeah, I've got one. I mean I I I'm on this pet mission to sort of uh build systems that would impose liability on intermediaries, right? Because I do think that it's
a it's they profit a lot from all of these scams and hacks and transaction fees, but no one talks about it. But so in my view, there should be a system where in the event there's a compromised wallet, all these intermediaries are notified. They're put on notice. This this state of knowledge is the first step all right that the law has you that the law requires for you to possibly say hey you know you should also be responsible for for the hack and the fact that you're in receipt of misappropriated funds. So broadly speaking there there are two ways to go after not not go
after but two two instances where intermediaries may find themselves liable right the first is knowing receipt. If you knowingly receive uh receive stolen property, then you should give it back, right? And the law recognizes that. It's as simple as that. The second the second broad um cause of action, so to speak, it's called dishonest assistance. So maybe you don't receive the asset, but you helped you helped in the compromise. Maybe you're an operating company of a mixer. Maybe you retain some control over those those switches and handles. If you're put on notice, then the law does impose an obligation. It may impose an obligation for
these intermediaries to also say, "Hey, you know, you should be liable to these victims because if you didn't assist them, then they wouldn't have gone through." So that's this idea of notifying uh everyone of compromised wallets is something that we need to build. I think that there are already platforms out there where victims can can go and report uh their compromised wallet. But then the next step would be naturally to to notify everyone, right? We even had one one particular instance where we could have mounted a case for knowing receipt of an exchange on an exchange because right before the the assets moved, it was
flagged as a as a scam related wallet, but it still went through. And I know from conversations with GMs of the exchanges here in Singapore that their transaction monitoring systems should stop the systems are designed to stop all of these things. You see? So in summary, first we need that notice mechanism so that all these third parties are put on notice. Second, we need that burn and reissue remedy. So those those two things combined freeze the movement of assets onchain and you crowd them out to the these third party intermediaries and catch them there, right? And the intermediaries themselves might become a target. So I
mean those are my thoughts on how we could improve the current state of play to help victims get recovery. Very interesting Kumar and um you know using the transparency of the blockchain uh in our favor and you know making sure that accountability means that people play their part. I I hope your mission is successful. You you did mention burn and reissue me times and Amelia you know seemed to be optimistic about that. Is is that a practical option for for only a subset of digital assets or or you know for for our listeners what what kind of digital assets can you you can't obviously look
to a a large cryptocurrency and ask them to to to burn and reissue right you're talking about smaller projects um or or or what's the right way to understand that as a possibility not necessarily but I'll let Amelia take this question yeah I mean I I I I I I think it's a very practical question and it really depends on the the the issuers uh the developers because um you know to what extent they are willing to help and of course if we talk about large sum then query they you know whether or not um they they would be keen in doing that I mean
the the cases that we've seen in the past are all relatively smaller amounts um that said um I don't see a real distinction as to I don't see a principled um you know sort of distinction between why they could read for a small sum and not a large sum. Um but um you know I I I I I don't think there are any clear you know framework um governing that. So which is why I think I go back to to um you know Kumar's point about um allocating risk in the in in in in the in the first instance in contracts because if you can
if you can ask them to to to um include that as a potential remedy then then why not? Yeah. Okay. Absolutely. I mean, that's the that has to be the starting point. Now, putting it into the contracts. Important to consider what you're signing, what you're agreeing to, and to to protect yourself on these considerations up at the be at the beginning of the relationship rather than after the fact. But I I've taken up a lot of everyone's time. I really really appreciate the the fascinating discussion we've had here. Hopefully, an uplifting and positive uh message for those who might be worried or or impacted like
by these topics. really appreciate uh everybody's expertise and contributions. So, thank you so much, Amelia, Kumar, Michael. Really appreciate you joining the session. As I've shared earlier, we'll be back in touch with edits and uh letting you review those before they're shared and welcome your thoughts or any any adjustments you'd like us to make. Really appreciate your time. Just to remind you again, when we finish the call, please just let your your browser window window or your page stay open until you see that the Riverside uh um screen tells you that you've been fully uploaded and that will help us get the best quality for
this uh this session. So, thank you so much again everybody. Really appreciate your time. Thanks so much guys. Really appreciate your time as well. Thanks everyone. Thank you. You too. Thanks. Have a good week. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Thank you.
Is cryptocurrency legal in Singapore?
Yes. Cryptocurrency is legal to own and trade in Singapore, but the businesses that provide crypto services are regulated. Exchange and transfer services are “digital payment token” services under the Payment Services Act 2019 and must be licensed by MAS and comply with anti-money-laundering rules. MAS actively discourages retail speculation through marketing and product restrictions.
Is cryptocurrency property under Singapore law?
Yes. In ByBit Fintech Ltd v Ho Kai Xin [2023] SGHC 199 the High Court held that crypto assets are property capable of being held on trust and are choses in action. Earlier cases (CLM v CLN [2022] SGHC 46 and the CHEFPIERRE NFT case [2022] SGHC 264) reached consistent conclusions for cryptocurrency and NFTs respectively. This means stolen digital assets can attract proprietary remedies.
Do I need a MAS licence to run a crypto business in Singapore?
Usually, yes. Providing digital payment token services, such as dealing in or facilitating the exchange of cryptocurrencies, requires a licence under the Payment Services Act 2019. Separately, a Singapore-based firm that serves only overseas customers needs a Digital Token Service Provider licence under the FSMA 2022, which MAS has indicated it will rarely grant. The right classification depends on your activity and customer base.
Can Singapore courts freeze stolen crypto?
Yes. The Singapore High Court can grant proprietary injunctions to preserve specific assets and worldwide freezing (Mareva) injunctions to stop dissipation, alongside disclosure orders compelling exchanges to reveal account information. In CLM v CLN the court granted such relief even against unidentified “persons unknown”. Because on-chain transfers are fast and irreversible, applying early is critical.
Can stolen crypto be recovered across borders?
It is possible but not guaranteed. Singapore’s courts have strong tools and can permit service abroad and by alternative means such as via a defendant’s wallet or social media. Actual recovery depends on tracing the assets on-chain, identifying who holds them, and securing enforcement or co-operation in the jurisdiction where the assets sit. Speed and coordinated legal action significantly improve the chances.
How are stablecoins regulated in Singapore?
MAS finalised a framework for single-currency stablecoins on 15 August 2023. It applies to stablecoins pegged to the Singapore Dollar or a G10 currency and issued in Singapore, and sets requirements on reserve backing, valuation, redemption at par, capital and disclosure. Only issuers that meet the full framework may label their tokens as “MAS-regulated stablecoins”.
Are retail investors restricted from trading crypto in Singapore?
Retail access is not banned, but it is constrained. MAS guidelines say DPT providers should not promote services to the public, must not offer trading incentives, cannot provide financing, margin or leverage to retail customers, cannot accept locally issued credit cards for crypto, and are restricted from offering lending or staking of tokens to retail customers. These measures took effect from October 2024.
Since 20 October 2026, a Singapore company filing its ACRA annual return must confirm that the particulars of its directors, chief executive officers, secretaries, auditors…
An Employment Pass holder can own a Singapore company, but cannot work for it on the current pass. Here is what MOM allows, where the…
What to collect from your current transfer pricing adviser, the S$10 million documentation test, and how to meet the 30 November 2026 deadline.